CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
Aug. 18, 2008 – 11:05 p.m.
2008 Election Forecast: McCain Pretty Comfortable in His Arizona Home
By Marie Horrigan, CQ Staff
CQ Politics Presidential Race Rating: Republican Favored
Electoral Votes: 10
It is pretty implausible to envision John McCain not carrying Arizona, where he has won four Senate elections by one-sided margins, taking 76 percent of the vote last time in 2004.
History is surely on McCain’s side. The home state of the late Barry Goldwater, the longtime senator who lost a national landslide as the 1964 GOP presidential nominee, Arizona has voted Republican in 13 of 14 presidential elections since favoring Democrat Harry S Truman in 1948. The only exception was President Bill Clinton, who carried the state by a 2 percentage point margin as he won re-election in 1996.
But as in other states, McCain is viewed skeptically by many hard-core conservatives because of his maverick opposition to party orthodoxy on some issues, including the volatile subject of how to deal with illegal immigration. This was a factor in McCain’s so-so showing in the Feb. 5 “Super Tuesday” presidential primary in Arizona. He won, but with a 47 percent plurality and a less-than-overwhelming margin over former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, who had 34 percent.
McCain’s Arizona base has been squeezed at the other end of the spectrum as well. The strong level of cross-party support he typically drew from independents and even Democrats dwindled as, in preparing to run for president this year, he courted national conservative interests that opposed his bid against George W. Bush for the Republican presidential nomination in 2000. “McCain has had a love-hate relationship in Arizona for a long time,” state pollster Earl de Berge said. “He’s working hard to ameliorate those things, but I don’t think that the effort so far has suggested he’s going to rise anywhere up to the kinds of numbers you’d expect a ‘favorite son’ to have.”
And McCain’s advantage over Barack Obama in particular is not as overwhelming as one might expect. The huge overall growth of the state’s population, including a surge in Hispanics, who make up more than a quarter of all residents, has eroded the GOP’s once-overwhelming strength.
“If McCain were not running for president, then Obama probably would have a very good chance of carrying Arizona,” said Bruce Merrill, a professor at the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University. He added, “I think the chances of him actually defeating McCain are not great, but not impossible, and my guess is it will be closer than a lot of people think.”
McCain can depend on support in large parts of suburban Phoenix and in the more rural farm-and-ranch lands around the state, but the state’s large constituency of independent voters also is much less inclined to lean Republican. The newer members of this swing-voting group tend to be much younger and more family oriented than their predecessors.
In 2006, the state’s independents were heavily focused on Iraq and Democrats benefited. One reason why Gov. Janet Napolitano won an easy re-election victory and the party captured two House seats is that independents were heavily focused on Iraq. “They were very, very anti-war,” Merrill said of independent voters that year. The Democrats, now tied 4-4 in the state’s congressional delegation, are shooting for their first majority in 40 years.
The party is aiming for another House takeover in the sprawling northeastern district where three-term Republican Rep. Rick Renzi , now facing federal corruption charges, is retiring. Though district voters favored Bush by 9 points in 2004 and Renzi deflected a determined challenge by 8 percentage points in 2006, Democratic strategists view this as a top-priority target. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee has pledged strong support for former state Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick, even though she faces a Sept. 2 primary. She raised almost $1 million by June 30; Sydney Hay, who heads the trade association for Arizona’s mining companies, is the best-funded GOP primary hopeful. CQ Politicsrates this race Leans Democratic.
The GOP is trying hard to win back the two House seats, but each appears to be a struggle.
State Senate President Tim Bee is the Republican Party’s strongest congressional challenger, taking on freshman Gabrielle Giffords , who won the seat of retiring GOP Rep. Jim Kolbe. Giffords represents the southeastern district that includes part of Tucson. Bee has posted strong fundraising numbers and has name recognition from his role as a state legislative leader. But Giffords has been one of the best fundraisers among freshmen Democrats and has worked hard on constituent outreach. CQ Politics race rating: Leans Democratic.
2008 Election Forecast: McCain Pretty Comfortable in His Arizona Home
The other district targeted by the Republicans takes in part of Phoenix and all of the large suburbs of Scottsdale and Tempe. Republicans argue that it was only the voters’ bad mood in 2006 that enabled Democrat Harry E. Mitchell , a state senator and former longtime Tempe mayor, to unseat six-term Republican Rep. J.D. Hayworth. But Mitchell has been able to build support unimpeded by competition for the Sept. 2 primary, while the GOP had to wait for a winner from its crowded and testy contest. CQ Politics also rates this race Leans Democratic.
In more of a long-shot bid, Democrat Bob Lord is challenging seven-term GOP Rep. John Shadegg in his heavily Republican northern Phoenix district. District voters gave Bush 58 percent in 2004, and Republicans hold a 14-point lead in voter registration. Lord, a tax attorney, sent notice of his serious intention with strong early fundraising. CQ Politics race rating: Republican Favored.


Comments
1. Were the secretary of state -the de facto lieutenanat governor here- a Democrat who also happened to be on friendly terms with the chief executive, then Obama might already have selected Governor Napolitano, thereby making this a LEANS R or even TOSSUP venue. 2. "...4-4 split in congressional..." Actually it is 6 to 4 in favor of Republicans ("Congressional" generally means BOTH House and Senate, except when referring to the districts of... ) 3. Since the primary election does not take place until the 2 of 09, CD-05 Republicans are indeed still waiting - rather than "had waited".
I am an Arizona resident. I am also a registered democrat. I have many republican friends who have said the they are voting for Obama this year. John McCain is not safe in Arizona, nor is he comfortably ahead. Most people on both sides of the politcal spectrum do not like what he has become. The small base of hard core conservatives think that he is too liberal. The rest of us who are democrats, independants, or moderate republicans think that he has become much too cozy with the religious right who do not have a very large proportion of the population of Arizona. Also, with our large Hispanic population as well as people moving here from more traditionally liberal places such as California and New England, Arizona should prove to be a headache for John McCain.
Nicholas J B Ohh, your case would be more credible if you didn't immitate Fox News Channel, and skew things to suit your argument. What Ms Horrigan actually wrote, if you care to read it again, was "the GOP had to wait" not "had waited" as you quoted. Ms Horrigan's grammar is not perfect - but then when did an American have good grammar - but at least her meaning was correct, unlike yours, which either deliberately or through ignorance, distorted what was written. You do yourself, or your GOP friends, no credit by highlighting your ignorance.
Ari: You are also forgetting that there is a lot of pissed- of Democrats, that supported HRC,that are now going to support McCain. So I think Obama, might be the one with the really big headache come Nov. This party is not now, or will not be a united party come Nov.
"McCain Pretty Comfortable in His Arizona Home" Question: WHICH ONE?
Lampe, I know HRC supporters who are voting for Obama. In case you did not know this, HRC now says that she is more focused on being in the Senate than she is being a part of a new administration. It is clear to me that the supporters of hers who are hard core do not listen to her nor do they want to help her retire her campaign debt. It seems to me that many of the PUMA's are not really democrats. I am guessing that you are but what I am getting is that many of them are republicans trying to cause trouble in the democratic party. Also, do you live in AZ? I do. I am around people everyday, republican and democrat, who say that they are fed up with republican policies. I was only talking about Arizona. Just because McCain represents this state does not mean that he will win it. He has become way to cozy with the likes of James Dobson and Pat Robertson for most Arizonan's to be comfortable with. We are no longer a solidly red state. We are a purple state. That is why I say that Arizona should be a headache for John McCain in November. Obama won the nomination because he won more states than HRC did. If it were the other way around, I would have said that Obama should have stepped down and let her take it. It did not turn out like that. You may be one of the pissed off democrats. However, HRC has said to get over it and support Obama because she knows that she lost fair and square. What does it take for you to realize that?
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: