CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
Aug. 13, 2008 – 9:04 p.m.
2008 Election Forecast: Michigan - Down to the Wire
By Marie Horrigan, CQ Staff
CQ Politics Presidential Race Rating: Leans Democratic
Electoral Votes: 17
Democrats have carried Michigan in each of the past four presidential elections, but the home state of Republican Gerald R. Ford has a heritage as a battleground, and the past two elections there were so close that Barack Obama would have to work hard to hold it under the best of circumstances. His degree of difficulty was ratcheted up by the long-running dispute between the state and national Democratic Party organizations over Michigan’s rule-breaking Jan. 15 primary.
Obama’s ability to win the state depends primarily on three things: building the advantage he had over McCain in polls on the economy; offsetting concerns about his degree of experience on defense and foreign policy; and getting every possible African American voter to the polls. They make up is 14 percent of the state population.
Pocketbook issues are central to voters nationwide, but the situation in Michigan is more dire because of its dependence on a domestic auto industry that has taken a sharp downturn. The state’s unemployment rate was 8.5 percent in June, the highest in Michigan since October 1992.
Polling early this summer by the Lansing-based firm EPIC-MRA showed McCain with some of the same advantages over Obama that he held nationally, especially on defense-related issues. McCain polled better than Obama on the issues of terrorism and national security, and he had higher favorability ratings than Obama. “Putting aside how those undecided voters feel about issues or anything else, just that fact alone would suggest that at this point it would probably break toward McCain,” said Bernie Porn, president of EPIC-MRA.
Both major party nominees incurred some bruises in the state-mandated January primary, which was three weeks before the threshold date set by both the national Democratic and Republican parties as the starting point for most states.
McCain lost the GOP primary to Mitt Romney, but at least the national GOP didn’t discourage McCain from campaigning in Michigan. Obama not only agreed not to campaign, but joined most other Democrats in scrambling to pull his name off the ballot. Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York was the only major candidate who left her name on the ballot, and she went on to finish with 55 percent of the vote to 40 percent for an “uncommitted” line.
The DNC, as threatened, barred the entire Michigan delegation from the convention and resisted demands from the Clinton camp to reinstate the delegates based on the primary results. The party’s eventual decision to restore half a vote to each of the state’s delegates left some Clinton supporters feeling short-changed.
Obama, however, has made gains in polling soon after he began actively campaigning in the state. “It’s very close,” said Michigan political analyst Bill Ballenger.
With five-term Democratic Sen. Carl Levin a pretty safe bet to win re-election, the focus on Michigan’s congressional campaigns is on the takeover bids Democrats are staging for two Republican-held House seats.
Democrats are targeting GOP incumbents Tim Walberg and Joe Knollenberg in their effort to reverse the 9-6 advantage Republicans have held in the state’s House delegation since the implementation of a pro-GOP redistricting plan prior to the 2002 elections.
The suburban Detroit district in which Knollenberg is serving his eighth term is no Republican stronghold, as Bush edged Kerry there by just 1 percentage point in 2004. And the career low of 52 percent Knollenberg received in 2006 against a little-known challenger boosted him on this year’s target list for Democratic strategists, who recruited a top-tier challenger in state Sen. Gary Peters. CQ Politics rates the race Leans Republican.
2008 Election Forecast: Michigan - Down to the Wire
The 2006 election also whet Democrats’ ambitions in the south-central Michigan district that Walberg won that year. The district has been consistently but not overwhelmingly Republican. While Walberg is a favorite of his party’s socially conservative wing, some less hard-line Republicans still harbor hard feelings over his ouster of one-term Republican Rep. Joe Schwarz in the 2006 primary. Walberg won just under a majority of the vote and had a narrow 3 point margin over an underfunded Democrat in that year’s general election. He faces a much better-known challenger this year in former state Senate Minority Leader Mark Schauer, a recruit highly touted by Democratic officials. This race also is rated Leans Republican.




Comments
Not only does Obama have to contend with the late start (organising the state) but also the unpopularity of Governor Granholm and controversy regarding Detroit Mayor Kilpatrick and at least some members of that city's council. These factors, therefore, seem to make it either TOSSUP or LEANS R.
McCain doesnt PANDER to each vote like Obama does. Cactus John is the straight talk express. Unions have Killed Auto-manufacturers and are doing the same to the Airline and Steel industries. Obama is Mr Union and Mr Lawyer. Obama the Harvard Educated Ivy league Lawyer is a fraud. McCain will at least be true to American Values - hard work, loyality, honor, duty, country. Obama wants to change these values to bis city Liberal values of Me first, govt will fix your problems, and redistribute from haves to have less. Dont fall for the Obamination.
This will be a very difficukt win for Mr. Obama. The people of Michigan seem to really buy in to the MYTH of "Straight Talk" that McCain spits out. I hope they remember the last bit of "Strait Talk" he delivered about "More Wars and Fewer jobs".
The DNCC is missing the boat about MI R-11. McCotter has attacked Bush from the right about China. This arrogant fool can be defeated. This is a winable district.
I agree that this will be a close race. What Obama needs to win this race is to break into the solid Republican base in Western and Northern Michigan. Few Democratic Presidential candidates seek this vote, but there is a contingent of potential pro-Obama young students and moderate environmentalists in this region- particularly north of Lansing- that need to be motivated to vote. In addition to focusing on turnout in the urban areas, a concerted effort in Northern Michigan might provide the margin he needs to carry Michigan. If McCain chooses Mitt Romney as his running mate, the Obama camp is in serious trouble without expending tremendous additional resources in the state.
Who cares about Mitt Romney, his father was gov 40 YEARS ago. He wouldn't help McCain in MI.
Don't discount a shakeup in MI's 8th District, where Bob Alexander is taking a second run at 4-term incumbent Mike Rogers. Rogers marches in lockstep with Bush, and votes against measures like the recent bill that would help families keep their homes in the face of foreclosure. At a time when Michigan homeowners are losing jobs, losing homes and losing faith, Rogers is voting against their interests in order to further his political career. It would take very little for the 8th District to go blue, Rogers wins by a smaller margin every election, and its foolish to count out the underdof in this race.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: