CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
Updated Nov. 2, 2008 – 11:18 a.m.
A Year of CQ Politics Rating Changes: Steady Growth for Dems
By Peggy Girshman, CQ Staff
When we at CQ Politics published our first race ratings for the 2008 congressional elections, it seemed likely that Democrats would pick up some House and Senate seats — expanding the majorities the party won with its big upsurge in the 2008 elections.
But only the most optimistic Democrat, or the most pessimistic Republican, would have predicted that the Senate and House races would break so expansively the Democrats’ way, or that such a vast majority of the changes CQ Politics has made to its ratings would reflect stronger opportunities for Democratic pickups.
The ratings — which run a spectrum from Safe Democrat to Democrat Favored to Leans Democratic to No Clear Favorite to Leans Republican to Republican Favored to Safe Republican — are regularly re-evaluated based on developments in the individual races and in national politics. And since November 2007, Democratic chances improved in 14 Senate races and 74 House races. For the Republicans, there’s not much to cheer about: their chances have improved in just two Senate and 8 House races.
There are multiple reasons behind these changes. The die was cast by a national political atmosphere which, much to the Republicans’ dismay, did not improve after 2006, as President Bush’s unpopularity and a sharp economic downturn weighed down the GOP. More than two dozen Republicans, sensing that they would spend another two years in the minority in the next Congress, chose to retire, while few Democrats did. That gloominess spread, as the Republican Party had difficulty recruiting top-tier candidates to defend their open seats or challenge Democratic incumbents, even some of those who on paper looked vulnerable.
The Democrats, meanwhile, have been much more successful at raising money for their congressional campaign committees than the GOP and those committees are sharing their bounty with their challengers and open-seat candidates running for seats currently held by Republicans. Scandals have changed the nature of a few races.
A note of caution: just because a rating moved more in favor of the Democratic candidate in a particular race, it doesn’t mean that the Democrat will necessarily win. Republican candidates are still favored, slightly or strongly, in many of the races in which the Democrats’ prospects have improved. But the Democrats’ ability to “spread the playing field” is forcing the Republicans to spend their resources more broadly, raising the possibility of more Democratic takeovers — and forcing the GOP to mostly play defense instead of staging strong raids to takeover Democratic-held seats.
The list below documents the race in which CQ Politics has changed its ratings.
CQ Politics Race Rating Changes Favoring Democrats
Senate Seats
Alaska: Ted Stevens , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: Leans Democratic
Colorado: Wayne Allard , R, retiring
One year ago: No Clear Favorite
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Democrat Favored
Georgia: Saxby Chambliss , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: No Clear Favorite
Iowa: Tom Harkin , D
One year ago: Democratic Favored
Six months ago: Democratic Favored
Today: Safe Democratic
Kansas: Pat Roberts , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Republican Favored
Kentucky: Mitch McConnell , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
Mississippi Special Election: Roger Wicker , R (replaced Trent Lott , R, who resigned)
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
Montana: Max Baucus , D
One year ago: Democratic Favored
Six months ago: Safe Democrat
Today: Safe Democratic
New Hampshire: John E. Sununu , R
One year ago: No Clear Favorite
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Leans Democratic
New Mexico: Pete V. Domenici , R, retiring
One year ago: No Clear Favorite
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
North Carolina: Elizabeth Dole , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Democratic
Oregon: Gordon Smith, R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
South Dakota: Tim Johnson , D
One year ago: Democrat Favored
Six months ago: Safe Democratic
Today: Safe Democratic
Virginia: John Warner, R, retiring
One year ago: Democrat Favored
Six months ago: Democrat Favored
Today: Safe Democratic
House Races
Alabama 2: Terry Everett , R, retiring
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
Alabama 3: Mike D. Rogers , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Alaska At-Large: Don Young , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Leans Democratic
Arizona 1: Rick Renzi , R, retiring
One year ago: No Clear Favorite
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Leans Democratic
Arizona 3: John Shadegg , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
California 3: Dan Lungren , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
California 4: John T. Doolittle , R, retiring
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
California 26: David Dreier , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
California 46: Dana Rohrabacher , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
California 50: Brian P. Bilbray , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Colorado 4: Marilyn Musgrave , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: Leans Democratic
Connecticut 2: Joe Courtney , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
Connecticut 4: Christopher Shays , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
Florida 8: Ric Keller , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Democratic
Florida 18: Ileana Ros-Lehtinen , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Florida 21: Lincoln Diaz-Balart , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
Florida 24: Tom Feeney , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Democratic
Florida 25: Mario Diaz-Balart , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
Georgia 12: John Barrow , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democrati
Today: Democrat Favored
Idaho 1: Bill Sali , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: No Clear Favorite
Illinois 8: Melissa Bean , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
Illinois 10: Mark Steven Kirk , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
Illinois 11: Jerry Weller , R, retiring
One year ago: No Clear Favorite
Six months ago: Democrat Favored
Today: Leans Democratic
Illinois 13: Judy Biggert , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Illinois 14: Bill Foster , D
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
Indiana 2: Joe Donnelly , D
One year ago: Democrat Favored
Six months ago: Democrat Favored
Today: Safe Democratic
Indiana 3: Mark Souder , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Leans Republican
Indiana 7: Andre Carson, D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Safe Democratic
Indiana 8: Brad Ellsworth , D
One year ago: Democrat Favored
Six months ago: Democrat Favored
Today: Safe Democratic
Indiana 9: Baron P. Hill , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
Kentucky 2: Ron Lewis , R, retiring
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Leans Republican
Louisiana 1: Steve Scalise , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Louisiana 4: Jim McCrery , R, retiring
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
Louisiana 6: Don Cazayoux , D
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: No Clear Favorite
Louisiana 7: Charles Boustany Jr. , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Maryland 1: Wayne T. Gilchrest , R, defeated in primary
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: No Clear Favorite
Massachusetts 5: Niki Tsongas , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Democrat Favored
Today: Safe Democratic
Michigan 7: Tim Walberg , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
Michigan 9: Joe Knollenberg , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: Leans Democratic
Minnesota 1: Tim Walz , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
Minnesota 2: John Kline , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Minnesota 6: Michele Bachmann , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: No Clear Favorite
Mississippi 1: Travis W. Childers , D
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Leans Democratic
Missouri 9: Kenny Hulshof , R, running for governor
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: Leans Republican
Nebraska 2: Lee Terry , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Leans Republican
Nevada 2: Dean Heller , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
Nevada 3: Jon Porter , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
New Jersey 3: H. James Saxton , R, retiring
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
New Jersey 5: Scott Garrett , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Republican Favored
New Jersey 7: Mike Ferguson , R, retiring
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
New Mexico 2: Steve Pearce , R, running for Senate
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
New York 13: Vito J. Fossella , R, retiring
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Democrat Favored
New York 19: John Hall , D
One year ago: Safe Democrat
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
New York 25: James T. Walsh , R, retiring
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Democrat Favored
New York 26: Thomas M. Reynolds , R, retiring
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
New York 29: John R.“Randy” Kuhl Jr. , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: Leans Democratic
North Carolina 10: Patrick T. McHenry , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
North Carolina 11: Heath Shuler , D
One year ago: Democrat Favored
Six months ago: Democrat Favored
Today: Safe Democratic
Ohio 1: Steve Chabot , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
Ohio 7: David L. Hobson , R, retiring
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Ohio 16: Ralph Regula , R, retiring
One year ago: No Clear Favorite
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Leans Democratic
Ohio 18: Zack Space , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Democrat Favored
Today: Democrat Favored
Pennsylvania 3: Phil English , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
Pennsylvania 4: Jason Altmire , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Democrat Favored
South Carolina 1: Harry E. Brown Jr., R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Leans Republican
South Carolina 2: Joe Wilson , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Texas 7: John Culberson , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Leans Republican
Texas 10: Michael McCaul , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Leans Republican
Texas 17: Chet Edwards , D
One year ago: Democrat Favored
Six months ago: Safe Democrat
Today: Safe Democratic
Virginia 2: Thelma Drake , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Leans Republican
Virginia 5: Virgil H. Goode Jr. , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Leans Republican
Virginia 10: Frank R. Wolf , R
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Virginia 11: Thomas M. Davis III , R, retiring
One year ago: Safe Republican
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Democrat Favored
Wyoming At-Large: Barbara Cubin , R, retiring
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: No Clear Favorite
CQ Politics Race Rating Changes Favoring Republicans
Senate Seats
Alabama: Jeff Sessions , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Republican Favored
Today: Safe Republican
South Carolina: Lindsey Graham , R
One year ago: Republican Favored
Six months ago: Safe Republican
Today: Safe Republican
House Races
Alabama 5: Robert E. “Bud” Cramer , D, retiring
One year ago: Safe Democratic
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: No Clear Favorite
Florida 16: Tim Mahoney , D
One year ago: No Clear Favorite
Six months ago: No Clear Favorite
Today: Leans Republican
Kentucky 3: John Yarmuth , D
One year ago: Democrat Favored
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: Leans Democratic
New Hampshire 1: Carol Shea-Porter , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: No Clear Favorite
Pennsylvania 6: Jim Gerlach , R
One year ago: Leans Republican
Six months ago: Leans Republican
Today: Republican Favored
Pennsylvania 11: Paul E. Kanjorski , D
One year ago: Safe Democratic
Six months ago: Safe Democratic
Today: No Clear Favorite
Pennsylvania 12: John P. Murtha , D
One year ago: Safe Democratic
Six months ago: Safe Democratic
Today: Leans Democratic
Texas 22: Nick Lampson , D
One year ago: Leans Democratic
Six months ago: Leans Democratic
Today: No Clear Favorite
First posted Oct. 24, 2008 10:11 p.m.




Comments
I hope it turns out that the executive and legislative branches are both democratic. I believe Democrats can handle this better than the Republicans did in the first 6 years of the Bush administration, and we won't be tied up for long periods while they fight it out. If worse comes to worse, we can always vote them out in 2-4 years.
One of the major needs of a president is to be able to work with people, to listen to people and be able to change your views if theirs are better. McCain does not do this. He is stubborn, ornery and even many of his own party say he is very difficult to work with. This "I have been tested" slogan of his makes me ill. He was not tested being a POW to be President. You are not tested until you sit in that chair in the Oval Office.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: