CQ TODAY PRINT EDITION
Jan. 14, 2009 – 8:02 p.m.
Stimulus Dialog Unlikely to Yield Big GOP Support
By Edward Epstein, CQ Staff
President-elect Barack Obama ’s economic stimulus train is leaving the station, and some House Republicans are looking for ways to get their ideas on board.
Others — perhaps most of them — seem ready to oppose his first major initiative.
The minority party faces complicated political math as it tries to figure out its response to the package being pushed by the incoming Democratic president who has made bipartisan dialog a watchword. Complicating the Republicans’ calculation is the economy’s continuing slump and increasing public clamor for major action from Washington.
For House Republicans from competitive districts, opposing Obama in the earliest days of his honeymoon period on legislation that polls show is widely popular could carry risks in the 2010 elections. Other Republicans want to see the whole package’s balance of tax cuts and new spending before deciding if they can support it.
But no matter how the plan shapes up, many Republicans are sure to vote against the plan that Democrats want on Obama’s desk by mid-February.
GOP leaders, even if they eventually decide to oppose the package that is expected to total some $775 billion to $850 billion, have to go easy on criticizing Obama because of his popularity and continuing efforts to lower the heat of the Capitol’s partisan rhetoric. The leaders, who met with Obama two weeks ago, are taking him up on his invitation to offer ideas.
On Thursday, a special House Republican economic policy study group will convene a hearing on GOP policy suggestions from such party stars as 2008 presidential contender Mitt Romney and former eBay CEO Meg Whitman, a top adviser to Sen. John McCain , the 2008 Republican presidential nominee.
Minority Whip Eric Cantor , R-Va., said the economic group was formed to take up Obama on his call for GOP ideas. “I’m hopeful. I take the president-elect at his word that he wants Washington to start working in different ways,” he said.
Some House GOP members, anticipating that the rule under which the chamber will consider the stimulus bill won’t allow them to offer much in the way of amendments, are already directing fire at what they call the unfairness of Speaker Nancy Pelosi , D-Calif., rather than tackling Obama.
Tax Cuts Key to GOP Support
The total size of tax cuts in the package could determine how many House GOP votes the stimulus gets when it comes to the floor in the next few weeks, said University of Virginia political analyst Larry Sabato. Some $300 billion of the package probably will go for tax cuts and incentives and that could provide Republicans a reason to vote for it, he said.
“For those from hard-core districts there is no incentive to vote for it. But those from competitive districts are looking for a reason to give him support so they can say in 2010 that they supported President Obama some of the time,” Sabato said.
Forty House Republicans joined 249 Democrats on Wednesday in voting to expand the State Children’s Health Insurance Program (
One Republican who hasn’t shut the door on supporting the stimulus package is Rep. Adam H. Putnam , R-Fla., former Republican House Conference chairman. “Republicans want to see the size and content of the plan and we want to scrub it” to make sure that Democrats carry through their pledge to exclude any earmarks, he said. “And it needs to be truly stimulative,” added Putnam, whose state has been particularly hard hit by the real estate bust.
The Republican Study Committee (RSC), the conservative bloc that includes more than 100 of the 178 House Republicans as members, introduced its own stimulus bill (
RSC leaders’ comments show that the majority of Republicans are sure to oppose the Democratic package. “This top-down approach of throwing money, at printing money” to pay for increased government spending “is not going to work,” said RSC member Phil Gingrey , R-Ga.
John Kline , R-Minn., said that even with their 256-178 majority, Democrats are still afraid of allowing the RSC to put its ideas up for a floor vote. “I hope the speaker allows Republican input. . . . We’re asking for an opportunity to bring our ideas forward and have a debate.”
RSC Chairman Tom Price , R-Ga., said he hopes there is room in the bill for some of his group’s ideas. “I’m hopeful that the spirit of bipartisanship that the president-elect apparently embraces sincerely will impact on the House.
“The president-elect wants our ideas. . . . We’ll see what he embraces,” Price added.
House Majority Leader Steny H. Hoyer , D-Md., conceded that for all the talk of bipartisanship on the economy, only a minority of House Republicans will end up supporting the stimulus in the end. “They would be foolish not to support this,” he said, because the package being drafted will meet some of their demands for tax cuts. “We need both tax cuts and spending, which this bill will have.”
But asked if only a small group of GOP members would side with Obama, Hoyer said, “You’re right.”




POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: