CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
– ECONOMIC AFFAIRS
Updated Jan. 27, 2009 – 3:12 p.m.
Republicans Urge Obama To Amend Stimulus Plan
By Edward Epstein and Alan K. Ota, CQ Staff
House Republican leaders, who earlier blasted the $825 billion stimulus package the House is about to tackle, emerged from a meeting with President Obama on Tuesday praising his willingness to consider their ideas for changing it.
Their Senate counterparts, always less vociferous in their attacks on the plan, also welcomed Obama’s efforts to court the minority. He met with them for nearly an hour after a 75-minute session with House GOP members.
The president said, “I recognize we’re not going to get 100 percent support but I think everyone felt good that I came here.”
“I think that we’re still working through the process, but I’m very grateful for both Leader Boehner and Leader McConnell to bring us over here, give me a chance to say my piece,” Obama said, referring to House Minority Leader John A. Boehner , R-Ohio, and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell , R-Ky.
The House was scheduled to begin debate on its Democratic-drafted stimulus package (
House Republicans said that Obama defended the existing stimulus package but assured them there were would be room to incorporate some changes during negotiations between the House and Senate over a final version.
Several members said they still plan to vote against the House bill Wednesday but would take another look when a final version comes back to the House.
“Sometimes you have to vote no the first time around,” Rep. Jack Kingston , R-Ga., said. “The real test will be what happens a week from now.”
“The most encouraging statement the president made was that he had no pride of authorship” over the House bill, said Minority Whip Eric Cantor , R-Va. “I took that to mean that tomorrow’s vote is a first step.”
Rep. Henry E. Brown Jr. , R-S.C., described the meeting as having “a relaxed atmosphere. Everybody was jovial.” He added that from Obama’s remarks “it was pretty evident that he had a good handle on the content of the bill.”
Rep. Peter T. King , R-N.Y., said Obama drew laughter and cheers from the lawmakers when he agreed to extend the question and answer period from 25 minutes to 30 minutes, even though it would make him late to meet GOP senators.
King said Obama told them “The Senate can wait. You see I can pander with the best of you.”
House GOP Conference Chairman Mike Pence of Indiana said prior to the meeting that Democrats had drafted a purely partisan bill. He said Republican leaders would undertake a public campaign against it. “The American people need to know that President Obama’s call for compromise has been completely ignored.”
But Pence, Boehner and other Republicans warmly praised the president’s effort to elicit their views and to work with them in addressing the economic meltdown.
Boehner, who was among a bipartisan, bicameral group of leaders who met with Obama Jan. 23 at the White House to discuss the stimulus, said members had urged the president to accept more of their tax-cut ideas, arguing that section of the package is not large enough. Republicans also objected to the size and details of the proposed spending in the measure.
Flexible on Details
While Obama didn’t promise major changes to the package, GOP members said he showed flexibility on some issues.
“The president did say he has some concerns over the spending proposals he sees in this bill,” Boehner said.
Participants said Obama took about 10 questions. Peter J. Roskam, R-Ill., had one of the more charged exchanges with Obama, after complaining that House Democratic leaders had shut out GOP amendments and seemed to be taking a much less compromising approach than the negotiated bipartisan approach suggested by Obama.
“He said he would be open to hear about tax breaks for small business. I might get back to him,” Roskam said.
Obama asked Republicans to speak up if they thought the provisions of the stimulus would not work. Todd Akin of Missouri responded by saying he doubted that the spending in the package would have a timely effect. “I told him my concern was two-fold. The first thing was the assumption that a whole lot of spending was necessary. The second one was that the tax cuts he’s talking about are not tax cuts that are immediately helpful,” Akin said. Akin said Obama replied that they had a different economic point of view.
Participants said Obama strongly defended refundable tax breaks aimed at low-income families that are in the stimulus measure.
Several participants, including Scott Garrett of New Jersey, reported that Obama said he would be open to a corporate tax rate cut if it was coupled with the elimination of tax loopholes. “It’s the beginning of a dialog,” Garrett said. “I was pleased to hear he would consider a corporate rate cut.”
Garrett said Obama’s comment came up in a question and answer session after he made brief remarks. “It’s impressive; he’s only been in office for a week, and he’s already meeting with Republicans. He looks you in the eye when he talks to you,” said Donald Manzullo of Illinois.
The House Republicans continued to grumble, however, about being ignored by Democratic leaders who drafted the bill headed to the floor.
“House Democrats have completely ignored the president’s call for bipartisan cooperation,” said Pence.
“We urged him to challenge Democrats to sit down with Republicans,” said Rep. Kevin Brady , R-Texas.
The Republican strategy of criticizing their Democratic counterparts while praising the popular new Democratic president ignores the fact that the House bill was hashed out over many weeks of negotiations between House Democratic leaders and key Obama advisers.
Some GOP members acknowledged as much, saying they doubted that Obama would be willing to make big changes in the stimulus package.
“I think this package has his brand on hit,” said Rep. C..W. Bill Young, R-Fla.
Democrats Sit Tight
Obama had no meetings planned Tuesday with congressional Democrats, but Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. joined his former Senate colleagues at the weekly Democratic policy lunch.
House Majority Leader Steny H. Hoyer , D-Md., criticized House Republican leaders for announcing their opposition to the House bill even before their meeting with Obama.
“I think its unfortunate, saying you’re going to vote against you” even before the meeting, he said.
Although he did not flatly rule out modification of the legislation, Hoyer said Democratic leaders aren’t inclined to make the sort of major changes that Republicans want. “I hope the bill stays in the ballpark we’ve set,” he said.
During a conference call with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi , D-Calif., Vermont Gov. Jim Douglas , a Republican, said,“If we were designing a plan we might each do it differently, and I certainly share the concern of the mounting federal debt. But economists say that in a serious recession, this kind of stimulant investment is needed. We really need to get this help to the states.”
Pelosi said, “We’re trying to get as much balance in it as possible, but it has to meet a standard. Does it create jobs. . . . Does it do so in a transparent way? We think it does. Let the legislation begin. Today it comes to the floor. Tomorrow we’ll pass it.”
Bennett Roth and Colby Itkowitz contributed to this story.
First posted Jan. 27, 2009 11:08 a.m.




Comments
The man is amazing, and since he he, don't you think we owe him the respect of addressing him as "the President" or "President Obama" in articles/blogs/etc.? It would be consistent with the ethic he is trying to instill in us all.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: