CQ TODAY PRINT EDITION
– HEALTH
Jan. 29, 2009 – 11:34 a.m.
Hoyer Indicates Action on Health Care Overhaul May Wait Until Next Year
By Alex Wayne, CQ Staff
House Majority Leader Steny H. Hoyer promised Thursday that he would put a health care overhaul to a vote in the 111th Congress, even if the economy continues to falter. But he did not commit to action this year.
The Maryland Democrat also said that he wants to overhaul the government’s big entitlement programs — Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security — as part of any plan.
Hoyer’s remarks came in a rousing speech to a friendly audience of liberal health advocates gathered in Washington for a conference sponsored by the left-leaning health advocacy group Families USA. In contrast, Sen. Charles E. Grassley , R-Iowa, told the same audience earlier in the morning that the economy could affect the breadth and success of any health care overhaul effort.
President Obama won office last fall on a promise that he would lead an effort to overhaul the health care system in a way that would guarantee coverage to every American and reduce the spiraling costs of care. Even before he took office, Democratic lawmakers in both chambers were scrambling to lay down their own proposals and promising to advance them quickly this year.
But since taking office, Obama has had to focus on the economic recession, and momentum for comprehensive health care action is slowing. Instead, Democrats are pouring money into existing programs through the economic stimulus package (
Leading lawmakers in both chambers, including Rep. Pete Stark , D-Calif., and Senate Finance Chairman Max Baucus , D‑Mont., now say comprehensive health care legislation could slip into next year.
Hoyer seemed to echo them Thursday.
“Health care reform is going to happen, because more and more Americans are waking up and realizing that this is everyone’s problem,” he said, after laying out a litany of problems with the current system. But as for timing, he said only that he was “committed” to bringing a bill to the House floor “in the 111th Congress.”
Grassley, too, offered no specific timetable for an overhaul. He is the senior Republican on the Finance Committee and enjoys a close relationship with Baucus. He said the two have been discussing ways to craft a bipartisan health overhaul plan, and he complimented a white paper on the topic that Baucus issued in the fall laying out his ideas as a precursor to legislation.
But Rep. Henry A. Waxman , D-Calif., the chairman of the Energy and Commerce Committee, said his panel might act sooner than Hoyer thinks. “I think he doesn’t realize that we can move quickly,” he said, but he did not offer a schedule.
“This is the time. This is the year,” he said in his own speech to the health advocates.
Cautionary Note
Grassley warned that the economy could affect their plans. Families USA Executive Director Ron Pollack, reading questions submitted by the audience, asked Grassley if there would be “sufficient political capital” to advance a complex health care overhaul after Congress has completed a bill aimed at restoring the economy.
“Yes, if what we do on the stimulus turns around the economy by next year, like we expect it to do,” Grassley said. “If the recession goes on . . . it wouldn’t necessarily prevent or discourage massive health care reform . . . but it might require a phasing or something of that nature.”
Hoyer disagreed.
“Economic conditions do not mean we can’t be bold,” he said. “In fact, they make our work more urgent.”
He cited a University of California political scientist, Jacob Thacker, who has produced research suggesting that a health care overhaul can act as an economic stimulus.
“I would argue vigorously against those who use the economy to argue to put this off,” Hoyer said.
Hoyer also said that an overhaul of entitlement programs should be included in a health care overhaul. President George W. Bush tried and failed to overhaul Social Security in 2005, in a scheme that Democrats derided as “privatization.” Obama has said he wants to try to overhaul both Social Security and Medicare.
Social Security’s trust funds are projected to become insolvent in 2041, and Medicare funds will run out much sooner, in 2017. Both programs can continue to function without trust funds, but their costs would consume much of the government’s budget.
“We can no longer afford to ignore entitlement reform,” Hoyer said.
Grassley agreed and said he wants the problems considered by Congress’ committees, not an independent commission, as some lawmakers have proposed.
John Reichard contributed to this story.




POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: