CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
Feb. 5, 2009 – 6:54 a.m.
NJ Governor: Steve Lonegan is No Bret Schundler
By Bill Pascoe, CQ Guest Columnist
As former U.S. Attorney Chris Christie formally kicks off his campaign for the Republican nomination for governor of New Jersey, the results of a new Quinnipiac University survey show he has a shot at becoming the first Republican to win a statewide race in New Jersey since 1997.
The survey showed Christie leading Democrat Jon Corzine in a hypothetical ballot test by a margin of 44-38 percent.
That’s the first time since September 2002 that a Republican has led a Democrat outside the margin of error in a statewide ballot test.
But Christie’s isn’t the only GOP campaign rejoicing at the survey results.
Former Bogota Mayor Steve Lonegan also has reason to be happy.
Lonegan is making his second attempt at winning the GOP gubernatorial nomination and attempting to pull off the same kind of anti-establishment-outsider campaign that propelled Bret Schundler to an upset victory in the 2001 GOP primary. This latest survey shows him in almost exactly the same position Schundler found himself in at this point in the race eight years ago.
The new survey found 49 percent of likely Republican primary voters viewing Christie favorably and 31 percent viewing Lonegan favorably. Eight years ago, according to a Quinnipiac University survey published on February 7, 2001, the favored candidate of the GOP establishment, Donnie DiFrancesco, had a favorable rating among GOP primary voters of 30 percent, while Schundler – who was making his first run for statewide office – had a favorable rating of just 16 percent.
The ballot test results were even closer.
The survey released Wednesday shows Christie leading Lonegan by a margin of 44-17 percent among GOP primary voters, while the survey at this point eight years ago showed DiFrancesco leading Schundler by 45-16 percent.
It’s almost a verbatim updating of the survey from eight years ago.
In each case, the establishment GOP favorite has roughly twice the favorables the outsider challenger has, and in each case, the establishment GOP favorite has a roughly 30-point lead on the hypothetical ballot test.
It’s no wonder Lonegan’s camp is rejoicing. If Schundler could do it, they reason, why can’t Lonegan?
Well . . . because 2009 is not 2001, and because Steve Lonegan is not Bret Schundler.
To begin, the campaign environment is totally different:
On the earned media front, for example, Lonegan will have a much harder time generating news coverage than did Schundler.
New Jersey is one of the few states that doesn’t have its own television market; consequently, the percentage of New Jerseyans who rely on newspapers is much higher than is found in other states. But newspapers in New Jersey are no different than newspapers anywhere else — they’ve all been going through tough times and many have had to cut back coverage. For instance, the New York Times (which broke several key stories in the middle of the 2001 primary campaign) no longer will play the role it once did in covering even New Jersey gubernatorial politics.
With less coverage from earned media, Lonegan will have to rely more on paid media. But for Lonegan , who has decided to accept public financing of his bid, spending will be capped at the same level as Christie.
Moreover, Schundler had the advantage of running against an incumbent with a long record of voting out of step with his party, and who was, shall we say, ethically challenged – as newspapers finally began to report, once he became the Acting Governor.
Lonegan, by contrast, doesn’t have the benefit of running against an ethically vhallenged incumbent.
In fact, he faces precisely the OPPOSITE task: Christie is best known as the corruption-busting U.S. Attorney.
How does Lonegan successfully contrast himself with THAT?
The only obvious contrast with the guy who put crooked pols in jail is to promise to let crooked pols go free. Contrast? Yes. Successful contrast? Umm, no.
So the media environment is different, and the strategic dynamics of the campaign are different.
By the time Bret Schundler announced his candidacy for Governor, he had, at that point, already spent eight years as mayor of the second-largest city in the state – a city, by the way, that had a voter registration of roughly 70 percent Democrat against just 6 percent Republican.
He also had a serious record of governmental success to tout: crime cut by a third, property taxes cut, jobs created.
He had a decade’s worth of fawning editorials in the Wall Street Journal, and a national fundraising base earned from a decade of helping Republicans across the country.
One could watch him work a room and envision him as a governor.
Steve Lonegan, by contrast, served as mayor of a tiny town of 8,000.
No one mistakes him for the governor candidate sent over by Central Casting, and his voice – now being heard on radio stations in New Jersey – sounds like something Mel Blanc discarded while trying to create the voice for Daffy Duck.
But perhaps the most significant difference between Schundler in 2001 and Lonegan in 2009 is this: In 2001, Lonegan supporters WERE Schundler supporters.
They were part of the Schundler Army.
But in 2005, the two faced off against each other in the GOP gubernatorial primary. Lonegan took a paltry eight percent of the vote – just enough to deny Schundler the victory, and throw it instead to moderate Doug Forrester. Schundler’s core supporters haven’t forgotten.
Will they be on a tear, determined to deny Lonegan the GOP gubernatorial nomination he denied Schundler four years ago?
Maybe, maybe not.
But they’re certainly not going to go out of their way to do him any favors, that’s for sure.
Bill Pascoe is CEO of The Foundation for American Freedom, a conservative think tank headquartered in Alexandria, Virginia. He managed Bret Schundler’s 2001 campaign for governor of New Jersey.




Comments
"NJ Governor: Steve Lonegan is No Bret Schundler " SAYS BILL PASCOE, THE BITTER FORMER MANGER OF SCHUNDLERS CAMPAIGN...
Bill, what campaign have you ever won? I know you hate Steve Lonegan but you really shouldn't talk about topics -- like winning elections -- that you know nothing about. When you've driven a lap in victory lane, you can talk about winning. Unfortunately, your desire to make yourself relevant continues to amuse those of us who have watched you fail again and again.
Mr. Pascoe is always trotted out for this kind of thing. It is amusing for him to try to tell us who can and who can't win. He has lost so many in New Jersey, most recently the very Republican seat of a state senator. Didn't he also lose the Speaker's seat in Illinois? Solipsism does drive out humility.
Is this the same Bill Pascoe that lamented Bret Schundler was not mayor during 9/11? Who said that Schundler would have won if not having to feed the "media beast" and is now saying that Schundler had an easy time of earned media? Can he get anything straight? http://gardenstatepol.com/blog/?p=312
watch the movie street fight and see Steve Lonegan and his supporters make fun of blind man for his fashion. The bloated lothsome sleaze. this man is a burden a cancer on new jersey
huh suburban liberal? lonegan is blind
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: