CQ TODAY PRINT EDITION
– EXECUTIVE BRANCH
Feb. 12, 2009 – 5:14 p.m.
‘It Really Wasn’t a Good Fit’: Gregg Withdraws as Commerce Nominee
By Jonathan Allen, CQ Staff
Sen. Judd Gregg withdrew his nomination to become Commerce secretary Thursday amid a political flap over the Census Bureau and congressional consideration of a $789 billion stimulus bill.
White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs issued a statement expressing regret about Gregg’s change of heart and saying it was a job that Gregg had sought. “Senator Gregg reached out to the President and offered his name for Secretary of Commerce,” Gibbs said.
Gregg was “very clear throughout the interviewing process that despite past disagreements about policies, he would support, embrace, and move forward with the president’s agenda,” Gibbs said.
When it became clear that wouldn’t happen, it “became necessary for Senator Gregg and the Obama administration to part ways,” Gibbs said.
Black and Hispanic leaders had taken issue with Gregg’s nomination because he had opposed President Bill Clinton’s request for additional funding for the 2000 census and because he had voted in favor of abolishing the Commerce Department.
A senior White House official told Congressional Quarterly last week that a decision had been made to have the Census Bureau director report directly to the White House, a move that appeared to assuage black and Hispanic leaders.
But it sparked outrage from House Republicans, who argued that the politically delicate process of counting Americans and collecting data on numerous aspects of their lives would be moved from the policy realm and into the political realm if the Census director were to report to the West Wing of the White House and Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel .
Gregg, R-N.H., said the Census flap was only “a slight catalyzing issue,” and not the reason for his withdrawal.
In a statement, Rep. Barbara Lee , D-Calif., chairwoman of the Congressional Black Caucus, said Gregg’s decision was the right one.
“When Sen. Gregg was first nominated, members of the CBC expressed concerns about his commitment to core functions of the Commerce Department like the census and minority- and women-owned businesses,” Lee said. “In his statement today, Gregg expressed ‘irresolvable conflicts’ on these very same issues. In light of this, we feel that his decision to withdraw is in the best interest of all parties.”
Gregg’s chances of being confirmed were strong, and his withdrawal was a surprise to colleagues and House members.
But ultimately, he appeared reluctant to take a job stripped of one of its key functions and to be in the position of defending stimulus legislation that most Republicans will not support.
A Need for ‘Effective Bipartisanship’?
“It really wasn’t a good fit,” Gregg said at a Capitol news conference where he went out of his way to praise President Obama. “It was my mistake, not his.”
“I readily admit that this was a huge error on my part,” he said.
Though they are from different parties, Gregg said, “There are going to be a lot of issues that I’m going to want to jump in on and carry his water.”
Sen. Mel Martinez , R-Fla., said Obama “misfired on this . . . but he ought to continue trying.”
“What we need is effective bipartisanship, not the appearance of bipartisanship,” Martinez said.
Gregg is Obama’s second pick for Commerce to step aside. New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson , a Democrat, dropped out because of a grand jury investigation in his home state, before Obama was sworn in and could officially nominate him.
Gregg said he would finish his term in the Senate, which runs through 2010, but will “probably not” seek re-election.
Democratic Rep. Paul W. Hodes has said that he intends to run for the Senate seat.
New Hampshire Gov. John Lynch , a Democrat, already had picked Republican Bonnie Newman to take Gregg’s seat if he were confirmed for the Commerce job.
Newman released a statement Thursday saying that she had spoken with Gregg about his decision to withdraw.
“I expect Senator Gregg’s decision was not an easy one nor made lightly,” she said.
Newman added: “For me, it would have been a great honor to serve in the United States Senate, but I will continue in my own quiet and non-political way to work on behalf of the people of New Hampshire.”
Rachel Kapochunas, Catharine Richert, Kathleen Hunter, Kathryn A. Wolfe and Alan K. Ota contributed to this story.




Comments
It is just as well that Gregg both withdraw (from head of Commerce) and retire (from Senate after '10): 1) As he himself apparently envisioned in '95, all the myriad functions of it may (easily!?) be ceded to other bodies, such as Small Business, Treasury, and Energy; and 2) "Eighteen years in Senate is long enough for one man" (ex-Senator Birch Bayh); Based on his career summary so far, that seems to be sufficient length of time for him, too.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: