CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
– POLITICS
April 4, 2009 – 7:05 a.m.
In Florida, a Democratic Primary Test for ‘Blue Dog’ Boyd
By Rachel Kapochunas, CQ Staff
Democratic state Sen. Al Lawson said he would like to take matters into his own hands after watching fellow Democrat Allen Boyd , who’s now in Congress, consider a run for another office.
“Every time an election comes up in Florida, he [Boyd] always said, ‘I’m looking at it.’ ‘I’m going to make a decision,’ ” Lawson said. “So I’m trying to help him make a decision.”
Lawson filed a statement of candidacy with the Federal Election Commission in early March to run for Boyd’s 2nd District seat.
Boyd, a seven-term House member, announced Jan. 28 his intention to run for re-election to his North Florida seat, quashing speculation he would be a candidate in the 2010 open Senate race. Others believed the fifth-generation farmer would run for state Agriculture Commissioner.
Boyd pursued a run for the Senate when Bob Graham (1987-2005), announced his decision to retire at the end of the 108th Congress, but Boyd’s lack of statewide name recognition prompted him instead to seek re-election to the House. Boyd has never gone so far as to file a statement of candidacy for another office.
Lawson notes that Boyd has rarely faced strong election challenges over the course of his 12 years in office and Lawson believes voters want to see a strong candidate challenge the lawmaker and offer a new perspective for the district.
Lawson mainly takes issue with Boyd’s record as a “Blue Dog” fiscal conservative. Lawson said district voters would prefer a “true Democrat” who is more left-leaning, such as Lawson himself.
“From my perspective, a Blue Dog is just a closet Republican,” Lawson said, casting himself as someone who is “committed to being a true Democrat.”
Lawson criticized Boyd’s vote against the stimulus and the congressman’s support for privatizing social security. Boyd voted against an initial version of the stimulus bill but voted for the version in conference, stating that the Senate had removed what he viewed as wasteful spending.
Bob Doyle, a consultant for Boyd’s campaign, said district voters have repeatedly shown they want representation by a “straight shooter” who is on the center-right side of some issues, including fiscal matters.
“Congressman Boyd’s been just that ... and voters have rewarded him with re-election,” he said, adding that Boyd has supported abortion rights, voted for the stimulus (PL 111-5), and been a “voice of moderation on fiscal discipline.”
“I think the congressman’s stewardship has been right down the middle,” Doyle said. President Obama has actively courted Blue Dogs this year on issues related to the economy and spending.
Boyd’s moderate viewpoint at home has also enabled him to hold onto his seat despite its GOP lean. The 2nd is a swing district where Republican John McCain won a majority of support in November, 54 percent, according to a CQ Politics analysis, at the same time Boyd won re-election with 62 percent of the vote.
Lawson believes Obama’s loss in the district, where 22 percent of voters are black, is more due to the Obama campaign’s decision to focus their Florida activity outside of the moderate to conservative Panhandle area of Florida.
Lawson, who is black, believes that running to the left of Boyd will earn him support from voters in the Democratic primary. When asked if support from the black community will directly figure into his strategy against Boyd, who is white, Lawson dismissed the idea, noting he has long found local support from both racial communities as a state senator.
Boyd weathered a strong African-American primary challenge once before in his first election to Congress in 1996 before the most recent redistricting. Boyd, then a state House member, was forced into a runoff with Anita K. Davis, a county commissioner and an African-American. Under old district lines, the 2nd was nearly one-quarter black. Boyd easily clinched his party’s nomination in the runoff.
Boyd won re-election easily until 2004, when he drew a well-funded challenger in state Rep. Bev Kilmer, who tried to cast him as a liberal. Boyd was the only incumbent Democrat in Florida with a GOP foe, and it was the state’s only truly competitive House race. But his popularity took him to a comfortable 62 percent victory.
Lawson recognizes he is the underdog in next year’s race, comparing himself to David of David and Goliath.
“I’m starting off from the bottom. The only thing I got in my hand is a slingshot, so I can’t afford to miss,” Lawson said.
Doyle said Boyd in the past has run aggressive campaigns and will weather whatever challenges, from Democrats or Republicans, are ahead for 2010, and he remained optimistic.
“From a 3,000 foot view of this race ... no challenger would intimidate me,” he said.




Comments
Both candidates are good men but only Boyd is likely to hold the district for Democrats.
If Lawson wins the primary it will set up the District for a Republican challenger to win. I cannot see this happening as Lawson's platform appears to be full of stuff that has been proven to be bad for the country.
Boyd voted for telecom immunity and to authorize the use of US armed forces in Iraq. I've been waiting for someone to run against him on his left, so Lawson's candidacy is good news for me.
my new goal is to support any democratic candidate left of any blue dog democrate and those republicans that keep dragging their feet on the nominations of Pres. Obama. Such as Tammy Duckworth for vet affairs and the iraq ambasitor. Im taking names and writing them down!!!!
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: