CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
– POLITICS
May 15, 2009 – 5:44 p.m.
Obama Persuades Congressman to Drop Senate Primary Threat
By Emily Cadei and Jonathan Allen, CQ Staff
Democratic Rep. Steve Israel announced Friday that he will not launch a primary challenge to Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand — at the request of President Obama.
“The president asked me to continue my leadership in Congress” and “not run for the U.S. Senate this year,” the five-term Long Island congressman said in a written statement.
The field-clearing overture in New York is Obama’s first known foray into the Democrats’ candidate selection process for the 2010 congressional elections, and indicates that the White House is prepared to take an aggressive stand to protect the party’s majorities in Congress.
Israel had been telling colleagues in the House that he would challenge Gillibrand.
He was one of several veteran New York officials passed over in January by Democratic Gov. David A. Paterson in lieu of Gillibrand — who had served just one U.S. House term — for the appointment to fill the Senate seat Hillary Rodham Clinton vacated to become secretary of State. He also was a member of a chorus of Democrats who argued that Gillibrand’s record as an upstate House member put her out of step with the left-leaning Democratic voting base on issues such as gun control and immigration.
But Obama intervened to dissuade him from his planned primary challenge Friday, Israel said.
Israel said he had received ample encouragement to run from across the state. But, he said, “In the interest of providing New York and our country with a united front for progressive change, I have decided ... not pursue a campaign for the U.S. Senate.”
“This is a tough, heartfelt decision for me,” he added.
The announcement drew an immediate — and positive — response from the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.
“ Steve Israel is a terrific congressman, and the people of Long Island are lucky to have him as their fierce advocate in Washington,” DSCC Chairman Robert Menendez said in a statement. Gillibrand, meanwhile, “is working around the clock, traveling the state, delivering for New York.”
Israel was considered by a number of insiders to be the most threatening among a handful of prospective primary challengers to Gillibrand. In addition to Israel, two Manhattan-based officeholders — nine-term Rep. Carolyn B. Maloney and Borough President Scott Stringer — and two from Long Island, seven-term Rep. Carolyn McCarthy and Suffolk County Legislature Majority Leader Jon Cooper, have been seriously considering the race.
Of those, Israel and Maloney are the only two with the demonstrated fundraising ability to run a competitive statewide race.
But some Democrats, most prominently senior New York Sen. Charles E. Schumer , have urged Democrats to rally around Gillibrand, expressing concern that a tough primary could make the seat vulnerable to a Republican takeover bid in 2010.
Former New York Gov. George E. Pataki has been mentioned as a possible Republican candidate, and recent polling show him with a slight lead over Gillibrand in a hypothetical matchup. Nine-term Republican Rep. Peter T. King , another Long Islander, has also expressed interest in running for the seat.
Israel’s withdrawal from the race does not mean the primary field is clear, however. McCarthy’s spokesman, Ray Zaccaro, said the Long Island congresswoman and staunch gun control advocate has not received a similar call from Obama.
“She has said from the beginning, from Day One, that she is going to keep an eye on Sen. Gillibrand and what she is doing in the Senate,” said Zaccaro, “and that she will step forward if nobody else does, but she prefers that someone else do it.”
Maloney’s spokesman said he did not know whether Obama had called his boss about the seat.
Maloney, who represents the eastern side of Manhattan, could mount a credible challenge from the left; she is the former co-chairwoman of the Caucus for Women’s Issues, earned a 100 percent rating from the AFL-CIO in 2008 and lately has been an outspoken advocate for reforming mortgage and credit card billing practices.
The nine-term congresswoman has indicated to colleagues that she plans to run.
But it is unclear what effect Israel’s decision — and Obama’s role in it — will have on Maloney’s thinking.
“I can’t imagine, at the end of the day, Carolyn Maloney running, knowing that Obama didn’t want Israel to run,” said a Democratic lawmaker.




Comments
Why this rush by Obama and Schumer to prevent Gillibrand from the getting a challenge by more progressive Democrats in a primary is beyond me. Her House voting record doesn't merit it and either Israel or Maloney could likely more easily win that Senate seat against a Republican challenge in November. Unless both of them ran in the primary against Gillibrand, either would likely be favored to win it. McCarthy could run a symbolic anti-gun campaign if she chooses, but she's not nearly the threat as are the aforementioned duo and it's clear she knows it. If she wants to stay in the Congress, she'll run for reelection. Unless Gillibrand's Senate voting record after 2010 is a substantial improvement over her House record, people like Obama and Schumer should hang their heads in shame. I hope they care about more than simply electing someone with a D after their name.
1. If Stringer, Maloney, Cooper, and McCarthy fail to coalesce around just ONE among themselves, then Gillibrand is likely to win, in a pattern eerily reminiscent of the 1976 primary contest (in which "neoconservative-minded" Pat Moynihan emerged victorious over a trio of left-wing opponents). 2. Should the real ire not be directed towards the (unelected) appointer instead?
Made him an offer he couldn't refuse.....Didn't want to end up in Fort Marcy Park, eh. Or, more likely, have the White House press core sicked on him.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: