CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
May 24, 2009 – 9:34 a.m.
Partisan Clouds Gather Over Missile Defense Plans
By Josh Rogin, CQ Staff
When Democrats meet Republicans on the field of battle over missile defense, Robert M. Gates will be providing them cover from up above.
The Defense secretary’s wholesale plan to reshape the military, as shown in the Obama administrations budget proposal, includes big changes to missile defense, namely terminating or gutting several high-technology systems and returning the enterprise, which received more than $9 billion last year, to its research roots.
The proposal is outlined in the fiscal 2010 defense budget request and the administration is using Gates’ credibility, his Republican bona fides, and his history as a supporter of missile defense to defend the proposed changes, experts say.
“They’re clearly relying on Secretary Gates and his credibility,” said Tom Donnelly, a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. “I’m not sure a Democratic secretary of Defense could do this as successfully.”
By presenting missile defense as part of an overall defense budget that is leveling off, Gates is forcing lawmakers to cut other prized programs if they want to advocate for increased funding for missile defense, said John Isaacs, executive director of the Council for a Livable World.
“Gates was very shrewd,” said Isaacs, “The squeeze has been put on the pro-missile defense forces, making it more difficult to restore funds.”
“We are not cutting missile defense capabilities,” David Altwegg, executive director of the Missile Defense Agency told reporters May 7. “Rather, we are reshaping and redirecting our technologies to improve and enhance our capabilities now and in the future.”
Gates stood behind his record to defend the changes at a May 14 Senate Armed Services Committee hearing.
“I’m a strong defender and proponent of missile defense,” he told senators. “But I want to spend the dollars on missile defense both on R&D and operationally where they will do us the most good.”
Along those lines, President Obama and Gates are proposing increased funding for near-term missile defense elements focused on theater defense and based on more proven technologies.
Democrats have been proposing similar changes for missile defense since reassuming power in 2007 but Republicans, aided by some Senate Democrats, were able to stave off most of those initiatives.
But with the administration and Gates working in tandem, many Democrats feel confident they can preserve the president’s changes to the program in the upcoming defense authorization and appropriations bills.
“There’s no question that the changes will be easier to sustain because of the change in the balance of power in the House and Senate,” said John M. Spratt Jr. , a member of the House Armed Services Strategic Forces Subcommittee.
Local Politics
Five specific missile defense components are forecast to be the battlegrounds during this year’s debate.
Obama’s budget plan would reduce the planned number of deployed ground-based missile interceptors in Alaska and California from 44 to 30, keeping the remainder as backups or testing devices.
Many GOP lawmakers are angered at the move.
“This is the one system that protects the homeland from ICBMs that’s completely on our land, our territory, that’s under our control without having to ask permission to place it in a foreign nation,” said Sen. Jeff Sessions , R-Ala.
The president’s budget also would kill two problem-plagued futuristic technology programs: the Kinetic Energy Interceptor (KEI), which was meant to hit missiles in their earliest stage, and the Multiple Kill Vehicle program, which was conceived to hit multiple incoming warheads at once.
Sen. Richard C. Shelby , R-Ala., wrote to the Missile Defense Agency (MDA) on May 13 calling on them not to halt the KEI project just yet. “Stopping work on the program now is irresponsible,” he wrote.
The new MDA complex is in Huntsville, Ala., as is the Army’s Aviation and Missile Command. Boeing, a major MDA contractor, also is moving its missile defense headquarters to Huntsville.
The budget would cancel plans for a second prototype airplane for the Airborne Laser program, which envisions shooting down missiles with lasers from 747 airplanes. House Appropriations Defense Subcommittee Vice-Chairman Norm Dicks , D-Wash., is a staunch defender of the program. The planes would be built by Boeing Co. in his state.
No funding is suggested in the budget request to build two planned missile defense sites in Europe, following Obama’s promise not to move forward until more testing is completed and agreements with the host nations Poland and the Czech Republic are signed.
Republicans say stalling work on the European sites risks damaging diplomatic outreach to the two countries.
“It leaves the Poles and Czechs and all of those who have been courageous in this effort fundamentally and objectively betrayed,” said Rep. Trent Franks , R-Ariz.
Staying Alive
Despite what looks like an uphill climb, Republicans aren’t giving up the fight to increase overall missile defense funding and save targeted components.
Rep. Michael R. Turner of Ohio, the ranking Republican on the House Armed Services Strategic Forces Subcommittee, said the GOP intends to use amendments and parliamentary procedures to boost the MDA’s budget, which would receive $7.8 billion under the president’s plan.
They also will use missile defense cuts to criticize the White House for increasing the budget for non-defense programs.
“This isn’t an administration that’s been concerned about spending,” said Turner.
In the end, experts warn that even if Obama and Gates are able to sustain most of their proposed missile defense changes through the legislative process, supporters of missile defense components could preserve small parts on which to fight another day.
“Ultimately, Gates should prevail largely if not entirely on his missile defense proposals, but it won’t be a slam dunk,” said Isaacs. “It’s very hard to kill a program and put a stake in its heart so it never lives again.”




Comments
Well, this certainly seems poorly thought out in light of the North Koreans nuclear explosion and missle launches today.
With N. Korea and Iran test firing missles, China and Iran sending ships deep into international waters; the seeds of Clinton era folly have returned. Secretary Gates dispite media assertions doesn't enjoy the support of top flag officers, field commanders and sr. NCO's. Obama and the Democrats rely on Mr. Gates' "credibility" at their own peril...2010 & 12 are looming large.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: