CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
April 23, 2008 – 1:27 a.m.
Dem Barely Misses Takeover Win in Mississippi House Special, With Runoff Next
By Rachel Kapochunas, CQ Staff
Democrat Travis W. Childers led the field and just narrowly missed the majority vote he needed for an outright victory in a special election held Tuesday in Mississippi’s 1st District. Childers now moves on to a May 13 runoff with Republican Greg Davis, the mayor of Southaven, in a district that has a conservative lean and usually votes strongly Republican in contests for federal office.
Childers received 49.4 percent, just short of the 50 percent threshold, according to complete but unofficial returns. Davis received 46.3 percent of the vote and trailed Childers by more than 2,000 votes, staving off elimination only by running up a margin of more than 8,000 votes in his home base of DeSoto County. Four other candidates were on the ballot, on which party affiliations were not listed, and they combined to total the remaining 4.3 percent of the vote.
Childers now faces a three-week runoff campaign with an uncertain outcome. But his first-place finish marks the latest startling surprise for the Democratic Party, and the latest setback for a national Republican Party that has struggled to regain its footing since its losses in the 2006 congressional elections overturned its majorities in both the House and the Senate.
The Democrats have sought to maintain their 2006 momentum by competing aggressively in a series of special elections for seats vacated by Republican incumbents. They scored a major and symbolic victory March 8 when Democrat Bill Foster , a businessman and scientist, won the special election in Illinois’ 14th District from which Republican J. Dennis Hastert — the former House Speaker — had resigned last November. And there is a strong Democratic takeover campaign occurring in Louisiana’s 6th District where a May 3 special election will replace former Republican Rep. Richard H. Baker, who resigned in February to head a financial trade association.
Not long ago, a serious Democratic challenge in Mississippi’s 1st District would have seemed implausible. But Republican Roger Wicker , who first won the seat in 1994 and had dominated its House elections since, vacated the seat in December to accept appointment to the Senate seat from which Republican Trent Lott had resigned to pursue private sector opportunities.
Despite the fact that residents of the northern Mississippi district favored President Bush with 62 percent of their votes in 2004, Democrats saw an opportunity in Wicker’s departure. And Childers, who holds a variety of administrative responsibilities as chancery clerk in Prentiss County, proved an attractive candidate who projects an image as a conservative Democrat.
While Childers previously won the Democratic nomination for the regularly scheduled November election by breezing to a relatively easy win in the April 1 primary runoff, Davis had to slug his way through a bruising Republican runoff campaign in which he bested former Tupelo Mayor Glenn McCullough.
While the special election runoff will give the Republicans a second chance to reclaim their hold on the seat, it almost certainly will require an additional infusion of spending by the party’s House campaign arm, the National Republican Congressional Committee, which badly trails its partisan counterpart, the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, in overall receipts and remaining cash on hand. The NRCC plunged nearly $300,000 into the Mississippi 1 race, while the DCCC ended up spending about half that amount, according to independent expenditure reports available Tuesday on the Federal Election Commission’s Web site.
Based on the near-even split in the first-round special election voting, CQ Politics will change its rating on the general election race to No Clear Favorite from Leans Republican.
Childers campaigned on conservative positions, hoping to capture crossover voters who have favored Republican candidates in recent elections. Childers emphasized his “pro-gun” and “pro-life” positions, while taking populist stances on economic issues that included opposition to trade deals he deemed “unfair” to American workers.
Childers was endorsed by The Blue Dog Coalition, a group of House Democrats who define themselves as fiscal conservatives, as well as local newspapers including the Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal and the Columbus Commercial Dispatch.
Davis also emphasized his conservative positions, characterizing himself as a strong opponent of illegal immigration and abortion who would fight against liberal lawmakers in Washington, D.C. Davis locked up support from the state’s high-profile Republican figures, such as Gov. Haley Barbour .
The NRCC, meanwhile, sought to persuade voters that Childers, despite his conservative talk, would align with liberal Democratic leaders in Congress. The committee also ran ads accusing Childers of shoddy business practices and property tax delinquencies.
Dem Barely Misses Takeover Win in Mississippi House Special, With Runoff Next
There also was a regional flavor to the contest. Many analysts pegged the races as a contest between the east and west regions of the district, and Tuesday night’s vote totals proved that to be true. Childers held a base of support in the east, surrounding Prentiss County, and Davis won over voters in the west, where his DeSoto County base is located. Childers won a majority in all eastern counties except Lowndes, which includes the city of Columbus.
Davis and Childers each handily won their home counties. Davis received 81 percent of the vote in DeSoto, from which many residents commute to metropolitan Memphis across the border in Tennessee. Childers ran up 85 percent of the vote in Prentiss County, though its much smaller population left him with a margin of roughly 3,500 votes there, well short of Davis’ raw vote advantage in DeSoto.
A main focus for all candidates involved in the special election was drawing turnout while avoiding voter confusion when they got to the polls. Both of the major party candidates defeated in the April 1 regular primary runoff — McCullough on the Republican side and state Rep. Steve Holland on the Democratic side — had filed to run in the special election. Although both asked to remove their names from the ballot after their primary losses, they were declined because the ballots had been printed.
Mississippi Secretary of State Delbert Hosemann conceded Monday that “this has been a busy, and possibly confusing, time for elections in our state.” In his statement, he also reminded the public that McCullough and Holland had dropped their campaigns. Each ended up with about 1 percent of the total, with McCullough running slightly ahead of Holland. Wally Pang and John M. Wages Jr. also received small vote share on Tuesday.
The runoff will be the fourth election in less than 10 weeks related to the 1st District seat. Voters first went to the polls for the state’s regularly scheduled primary on March 11. McCullough placed first in the Republican contest and Davis placed second, while Childers came in first in the Democratic primary and Holland placed second. The four candidates advanced to the April 1 runoff in which Childers bested Holland and Davis came from behind to capture his party’s nomination.
The runoff winner will serve until at least January, when Wicker’s unexpired term in the 110th Congress concludes. The winner of the Childers-Davis general election rematch this November will be sworn in next January for a full term in the 111th Congress.




Comments
I actually think this whole thing is being exaggerated. This is an open race and Childers ran as a strongly conservative Democrat - sort of in the same league with Gene Taylor. Comparing Roger Wicker's margin to that of Davis simply isn't plausible. Open seats are always open to upsets and this is simply reading too much into the situation. Don't forget that polls show McCain thumping either Obama or Clinton in Mississippi and I'm sure in this district. So, while it's not exactly good news for the GOP that they're battling in some of these open races, it's not exactly surprising either. If Roger Wicker were running for re-election against Childers, he would have won in a cakewalk. By an odd contrast, this actually might bode well for Senator Wicker in November because he's so popular in a district that has more 'swing' in it than people orginally realized.
This is not a "swing" district by any means. It has a PVI of +10, meaning it runs about 10 points more Republican than the nation as a whole. For the DCCC to only spend half of the money of the NRCC and for Childers to do so well speaks to the national environment and the GOP brand. Yeah, McCain might be doing ok in national polling, but only because voters don't associate him with the Republican party as much. For these Congressional candidates who are cut and dry Republicans, they've got serious problems. If Republicans cannot hold onto a +10 district, or it takes hundreds of thousands of dollars to do so, they're in real trouble come November.
Races in the south, especially the open ones, hold more opportunities for democrats when the PVI is taken into account. Democrats would stand much less chances of winning a PVI (R) + 10 in say California and Michigan. The reason is of course that conservative southerners registered as democrats who vote republican for president, are more likely to vote democratic the smaller the race.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: