CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
Aug. 15, 2008 – 6:13 a.m.
Bob Benenson’s Jigsaw Politics: The Top 5 Senate Vulnerables, Revisited and Revised
By Bob Benenson, CQ Staff
Jigsaw Politics in July presented CQ Politics’ lists of the five seats most vulnerable to takeover by the challenging party, in three categories: the most vulnerable among all Senate and House seats, and the Democratic House seats most vulnerable to Republican challenges (which was included because the Senate and House Top 5’s, typical of this year’s partisan trend, were all Democratic bids to take over Republican seats).
Before we — and most of our readers — get swept up in the hoopla of the Democratic convention that starts soon, this and next week’s Jigsaw Politics columns are devoted to an update of those lists.
Today’s subject is the Senate list, which includes the biggest change from the original last month. The federal indictment of Republican Sen. Ted Stevens in late July, on charges of failing to report substantial gifts he allegedly received from a corporate ally, has greatly improved the Democrats’ odds of taking over the Alaska seat he has held for 40 years, boosting that race into the Top 5 list.
Alaska supplants Mississippi’s Senate special election in the Top 5. While still rated as a tossup by CQ Politics, the contest has been marked of late by some bad press for the Democratic nominee, former Gov. Ronnie Musgrove, who is challenging Republican Roger Wicker , a House veteran appointed last December to fill a vacant seat.
Republican campaign operatives have been trying throughout the campaign year to tie Musgrove to the principals in a scandal involving the failure of a beef plant that cost the state millions in payments it had raised for the design and building of the facility. Two executives of the Georgia company at the center of the scandal recently pleaded guilty of seeking to influence Musgrove in 2003 by making a $25,000 contribution — deemed by prosecutors as an “illegal gratuity” — to the treasury for his ultimately unsuccessful campaign for re-election as governor. This contribution, according to local news reports, came on top of a $20,000 donation the company executives had earlier made to Musgrove’s campaign funds.
Musgrove, who says Republicans are using the incident to smear him, has consistently denied any wrongdoing, contending that he had no direct role in choosing the company and that their campaign donations did not sway his administration’s decision-making on the beef plant. And Democrats have been trying to level the field by tying congressional campaign contributions Wicker has received to spending “earmarks” that he has sought as a lawmaker.
For comparison purposes and more details about the contests, the original Top 5 Vulnerable Senate Seats analysis can be found here.
Top 5 Vulnerable Senate Seats
Virginia: The presidential campaign of Illinois Sen. Barack Obama announced this week that former Virginia Gov. Mark Warner — who is running to succeed retiring five-term Republican Sen. John W. Warner — will be the keynote speaker at the Democratic National Convention being held the last week of this month. The move was seen as a signal that Obama is following through on plans to seriously compete for the 13 electoral votes in Virginia, which has gone Republican in each of the past 10 presidential elections.
But the Democrats would not be doing this if they also weren’t fully confident that Mark Warner is going to win his Senate race, just as they felt certain about Obama’s prospects in his 2004 Senate bid when they picked him for a keynote speech that launched his meteoric rise in national politics.
And it again looks like the Democrats are making a pretty safe bet. Warner — whose highly popular tenure as governor from 2002 to 2006 set the stage for other significant Democratic victories in a state that long had been trending Republican — is heavily favored over his gubernatorial predecessor, Republican James S. Gilmore III, with the most recent poll earlier this month showing the Democrat with a whopping 24 percentage-point lead.
New Mexico: Nothing has changed of yet to shake the perception that five-term Democratic Rep. Tom Udall has a solid edge over Republican Rep. Steve Pearce in the contest to succeed retiring six-term Republican Sen. Pete V. Domenici . While Udall was unopposed for the Democratic Senate nomination, Pearce made the finals by narrowly winning a bruising primary, and the congressman faces a tough obstacle in winning over those supporters of Rep. Heather A. Wilson , his more centrist GOP opponent, who argued during the primary campaign that Pearce is too conservative to win a highly competitive swing state such as New Mexico.
Alaska: FBI and IRS agents raided Stevens’ Alaska home in July 2007 as part of a sweeping political corruption investigation involving the Alaska-based Veco oil field services company. This, in turn, emboldened Anchorage Mayor Mark Begich, the most prominent Democratic officeholder in the strongly Republican-leaning state, to launch a challenge to Stevens after a series of elections in which his party essentially ceded the seat.
Bob Benenson’s Jigsaw Politics: The Top 5 Senate Vulnerables, Revisited and Revised
That cloud of ethics controversy that hung over Stevens for a year burst into a storm when federal prosecutors charged he had failed to report more than $250,000, including major renovations to the Alaska house, an expensive car and a top-of-the-line gas grill, provided to him by Veco executives.
Stevens, the longest-serving Republican senator in history, has declared his innocence and says he will be exonerated. And if anyone could survive this kind of trouble, it is Stevens, a former chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee who has the gratitude of many residents of the remote state for the billions in federal spending he has helped steer home.
But it is clear that Stevens has been damaged by the indictment, with polls showing Begich jumping from a virtual tossup to a double-digit lead. The degree to which Stevens has been hurt by the flap will be tested in the state’s Aug. 26 primary, in which Stevens is most seriously challenged by businessmen Dave Cuddy and Vic Vickers.
New Hampshire. The Democratic trend that in 2006 carried the party to one of its most successful election years ever in New Hampshire continues to buoy former Gov. Jeanne Shaheen’s hopes of winning the rematch of the close race she lost six years ago to Republican John E. Sununu . The GOP incumbent can’t be counted out, though, because Yankee Republican traditions still run deeper in New Hampshire than in the rest of strongly Democratic New England, and because Sununu has a reputation as an intelligent and hard-working legislator. The latest polls sowed confusion about how close the Senate race is, with a July 11-20 Granite State poll by the University of New Hampshire showing Shaheen winning by just 4 points, and an American Research Group poll done July 17-19 showing her up by 22 points.
Colorado. As in Virginia, Democrats in Colorado have been making a comeback this decade after a long period of Republican gains. And Democratic Rep. Mark Udall , though hardly an overwhelming favorite, has an edge over his Republican opponent, former Rep. Bob Schaffer, in the contest to succeed retiring two-term Republican Sen. Wayne Allard . Though some polls have shown the race as a tossup, most have given Udall a lead of mid-to-high single digits.
The overall Senate election landscape underscores the likelihood of further Democratic gains after the six-seat pickup in 2006 that gave the party its current narrow Senate majority. As has been the case throughout the campaign, the only Democratic seat that is even close to eligibility for the Top 5 list is the one two-term Sen. Mary L. Landrieu is defending in Louisiana.
The GOP’s problems don’t end with the Top 5, as Democrats also are staging highly competitive challenges in that Wicker-Musgrove Mississippi contest; Oregon, where two-term Republican Sen. Gordon H. Smith faces Democratic state House Speaker Jeff Merkley; Maine, where two-term GOP incumbent Susan Collins is trying to fend off six-term Democratic Rep. Tom Allen ; and Minnesota, where there is a high-profile contest between first-term Republican Sen. Norm Coleman and Democratic nominee Al Franken, the well-known comic entertainer.
And Democratic strategists are trying to gin up serious longshot challenges to Republican senators who currently are heavy favorites, including Minority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, North Carolina Sen. Elizabeth Dole and Texas incumbent John Cornyn .
The Democrats’ aggressive candidate recruiting and targeting efforts are keeping alive the party’s still-longshot hopes for the nine-seat gain it needs to get to 60 seats — the so-called filibuster-proof majority, since the votes of three-fifths of senators are needed to cut off stalling tactics and proceed to a floor vote on legislation.




POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: