CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
June 8, 2008 – 10:51 p.m.
Mississippi Dems’ Upswing Begets Stronger Outlook in Key Fall Races
By Rachel Kapochunas, CQ Staff
Democrat Travis W. Childers ’ takeover of Mississippi’s 1st District in a House special election last month was at least an interruption in the Republican Party’s long ascendancy in the strongly conservative-leaning Southern state.
And a CQ Politics analysis of the upcoming general election contest for that seat — and for the November special election in which former 1st District Republican Rep. Roger Wicker is defending the Senate seat to which he was appointed last December — suggests that Childers’ victory is a harbinger of a very hazardous campaign year for the Mississippi GOP.
CQ Politics has changed its ratings on both the Senate and 1st District House races to reflect the strengthened Democratic Party position and the Republican Party’s increased degree of difficulty. These shifts were prompted in part by the Democrats’ recruitment of a prominent figure, former Gov. Ronnie Musgrove, as their challenger to Wicker, combined with Childers’ victory, which underscored the Democrats’ continued momentum in congressional politics since they gained their national Senate and House majorities with big gains in the 2006 elections.
The rating on the Senate special election has been changed to No Clear Favorite, or tossup, from Republican Favored. And for the 1st District general election — a rematch between Childers and Greg Davis, the Republican he defeated by 54 percent to 46 percent in the May 13 special — CQ Politics has changed its rating to Leans Democratic from No Clear Favorite.
These changes do not mean that the Mississippi Republicans are in retreat, nor does it means they do not have a competitive shot to win both of these competitive races. Arizona Sen. John McCain , the presumed Republican presidential nominee, is a solid favorite to win the six electoral votes in Mississippi, a state that Republican candidates have carried in the past seven presidential elections, with George W. Bush winning by margins of 17 percentage points in 2000 and 20 points in 2004.
Wicker and other GOP candidates could also benefit from the campaign organizing efforts of popular Republican Sen. Thad Cochran , who is up for re-election in this year’s regularly scheduled Senate contest and is considered a shoo-in to win a sixth term. And the 3rd Congressional District seat, left open by retiring six-term Republican Rep. Charles W. “Chip” Pickering Jr. , looks to be safely in GOP hands, with former Rankin County Republican Party Chairman Gregg Harper an overwhelming favorite for the general election.
Yet the Democrats’ greatly improved outlook in the state’s two competitive congressional races would have been unimaginable even two years ago, when Mississippi stood largely immune from the pro-Democratic tide that swept much of the nation. Mississippi voters in 2007 comfortably re-elected Republican Gov. Haley Barbour , gave Wicker 66 percent in his bid for a seventh House term and provided Republican Trent Lott, the former Senate majority leader, with an effortless victory for a fourth term.
But Lott decided last December, just one year into that term, to resign his seat to begin a private sector career as a lobbyist. That stunning decision set in motion the chain of events that have cast Wicker as the seriously challenged Senate incumbent and gave Childers his unexpected opportunity to capture Wicker’s former House seat.
Democratic Senate nominee Musgrove is seeking a political comeback after losing to Barbour in his 2003 bid for a second term as governor, a race he lost by 53 percent to 46 percent. But Musgrove, although he lost, was still well thought of by many voters when he left that office, and some state political analysts believe he holds significant advantages against Wicker in the Republican’s first statewide campaign.
“Right now it is in toss-up territory,” said Marty Wiseman, director of the John C. Stennis Institute of Government at Mississippi State University, when asked by CQ Politics about the Senate race. Wiseman noted that several recent polls bolster the idea the race could go either way.
A May survey commissioned by the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee found Musgrove with an 8-point lead over Wicker, 48 to 40 percent. A Research 2000 poll commissioned by liberal blog Daily Kos found Wicker with a 4-point lead over Musgrove, 46 to 42 percent.
Though “own” polls done for candidates and partisan groups tend to raise a shadow of doubt, an independent poll by the Rasmussen organization, conducted May 27, had Musgrove leading Wicker by 1 point, 47 to 46 percent.
Wicker has yet to strongly increase his name identification outside of his home base in northern Mississippi’s 1st District. Musgrove, on the other hand, enters the race with high statewide name ID owing to his gubernatorial tenure from 2000 to 2004 and a previous term as lieutenant governor.
Mississippi Dems’ Upswing Begets Stronger Outlook in Key Fall Races
Wiseman also believes Musgrove could benefit from a long-held reputation as an advocate for public education, from the time of his earlier state Senate service.
Republicans also readily admit that Musgrove provides Wicker with tough competition.
“He is probably the strongest candidate the Democrats could put up this election cycle,” said Republican consultant Brian Perry, who concedes this year’s Senate election is “definitely competitive.” But Perry, a former spokesman for retiring congressman Pickering, believes Wicker will advance in the polls once he introduces himself to more voters across the state.
Perry said Republicans are also likely to remind voters they “fired” Musgrove from his job as governor when he lost to Barbour in 2003 and will ask why Musgrove would be better as senator.
Wicker has the strong support of Barbour, a former Republican National Committee chairman, as well as the current national GOP leadership.
He also held a big early logistical advantage in the important realm of campaign funding. Wicker’s most recent report to the Federal Election Commission showed he had $2.8 million in cash on hand as of March 31, partly because federal campaign finance law allowed him to transfer over $545,000 he had piled up in his House campaign treasury. Musgrove reported just $337,000 on hand through the end of March.
Some Mississippi politics watchers speculate that Musgrove has personal baggage that will hinder his campaign, including his very public divorce while serving as governor.
Additionally, Republican officials have been trying to make an issue of Musgrove’s alleged connection to a scandal involving a Mississippi beef plant that failed in 2004 and cost the state millions of dollars in loans that had been granted for construction and operation costs. Some individuals related to the plant who have been indicted for bribing a public official reportedly donated money to Musgrove’s 2003 campaign.
But Musgrove has not been accused of wrongdoing and has denied any impropriety. Wiseman said he believes that if no new and damning information surfaces, the beef plant scandal “won’t be any more of a problem than it is now” for Musgrove.
While McCain is favored to carry Mississippi for president this November, Wiseman believes Musgrove could nonetheless benefit from Illinois Sen. Barack Obama ’s bid as the presumed Democratic presidential nominee. Obama’s campaign has boosted voter turnout among Democrats across the country, including among African-Americans, a constituency with voting participation numbers that typically run below average. Blacks make up 36 percent of the population in Mississippi, where Obama took 61 percent of the Democratic presidential primary vote March 11 to defeat New York Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton .
Wiseman asserts that Obama’s potential impact on Mississippi’s down-ballot races has already been proven by Childers in his takeover campaign for the 1st District House seat. Davis, the mayor of the northern Mississippi city of Southaven and Childers’ congressional opponent, ran a television ad during the House campaign that sought to portray Childers as a close political ally to Obama. The ad was an attempt to connect Childers, who ran as a conservative Democrat, to his party’s more liberal national leadership. But Wiseman said the plan backfired.
Wiseman said Childers “couldn’t have come up with an ad for himself that helped any more than that.” The longtime analyst of Mississippi politics believes that ad helped drive up overall Democratic and African-American turnout for Childers in the special election runoff.
Childers, a county clerk and nursing home owner, finished first in the initial round of special election voting on April 22 with 49 percent of the vote — just short of the majority he needed to win the seat outright — to 46 percent for Davis, whose support base was heavily concentrated in his home area, in the northwestern part of the district that is within the metropolitan sphere of Memphis, Tenn. Davis remained stuck in place in the subsequent runoff vote, while Childers advanced to victory with 54 percent.
Mississippi Dems’ Upswing Begets Stronger Outlook in Key Fall Races
The current consensus among state political observers is that Davis will have a very hard time making up lost ground by November, when Childers will have had several months of experience on the job.




Comments
Uh, no, I'm pretty sure Haley Barbour was "comfortably re-elected" in 2007, not 2006.
Thanks for the headsup! We have corrected the date of Gov. Barbour's reelection to 2007.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: