CQ TODAY PRINT EDITION
June 11, 2008 – 7:26 p.m.
Prospects Dim For Food Safety Legislation Despite Salmonella Scare
By Aliya Sternstein, CQ Staff
Despite a salmonella outbreak that has caused McDonald’s and Wal-Mart to stop selling tomatoes, prospects for passing significant food safety legislation this year are dimming.
“The window for Congress to take up comprehensive legislation to overhaul the food safety system continues to narrow,” said Rosa DeLauro , the Connecticut Democrat who has led the food-safety fight in the House. “Regardless of what happens this year, the real opportunity will be next year, with a new Congress, and importantly, a new administration.”
Outbreaks of e-Coli in spinach, tainted imports from China, the biggest beef recall in U.S. history and the recent warning linking salmonella to some tomato varieties have spurred a push in Congress to overhaul food-safety laws.
But with the congressional calendar dwindling and floor time in short supply, a draft House Food and Drug Administration overhaul bill has not advanced out of committee and Senate proposals have yet to be released.
Food-safety advocates say they may look for opportunities to address some of their concerns in must-pass appropriations bills. DeLauro, the agriculture appropriations subcommittee chairwoman, said she may try to insert some food-safety provisions in her spending bill that would build a “foundation” for broader legislation next year.
In the Senate, Agriculture Appropriations Subcommittee Chairman Herb Kohl , D-Wis., has yet to introduce legislation designed to address slaughterhouse operations. Kohl, who has repeatedly called for a strict ban on allowing “downer” cattle — animals that cannot walk — to be slaughtered for food may look to add the language to the farm spending bill, an aide said.
The Bush administration this week boosted its fiscal 2009 Food and Drug Administration budget request by $275 million, including $125 million for food safety.
DeLauro commended the administration for recognizing the problems, but she criticized the president’s proposals to offset the additional spending with cuts in other programs, such as a social services grant program.
Legislation Progresses Slowly
Senate Majority Whip Richard J. Durbin , D-Ill., said he remains confident that meaningful food safety legislation will come to the floor this year. But Durbin, who has joined DeLauro in pressing for a single food-safety regulatory agency, has yet to offer legislative language.
Meanwhile, the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pension Committee had just begun hearings on comprehensive food and drug safety overhauls when Chairman Edward M. Kennedy , D-Mass., was diagnosed with brain cancer.
“We’re optimistic” that Congress will enact “effective food and medical product safety legislation this year,” said Kennedy spokeswoman Melissa Wagoner.
But some lawmakers are less confident.
Prospects Dim For Food Safety Legislation Despite Salmonella Scare
“I don’t think there will be a bill this year,” said Sen. Dianne Feinstein , D-Calif. “I don’t know.”
In the House Energy and Commerce panel, Chairman John D. Dingell , D-Mich., has been holding hearings on his draft proposal for a sweeping FDA overhaul, which would establish user fees for all domestic and foreign food producers and spend the money on inspection and safety activities.
An Energy and Commerce subcommittee scheduled an FDA oversight hearing on Thursday that will address food-safety issues.
“We will continue working on this legislation as long as it takes to get it right,” Dingell said.
Some lawmakers are content to see the food safety legislation moving slowly. Rep. Jack Kingston of Georgia, the ranking Republican on the Agriculture Appropriations subcommittee, says industry is regulating itself just fine.
“I don’t think the case is there for the Dingell bill at the moment,” he said.
Kingston said the 5,000 annual deaths from food-related illnesses, according to the Centers for Disease Control, is tiny compared to the millions of Americans consuming billions of pounds of food, and isn’t a crisis worthy of boosting the FDA budget by $275 million.
“Five thousand deaths may be insignificant to some, but that is not my view, and I imagine it’s not the view of American consumers, especially those who’ve lost loved ones,” Dingell shot back.
But Kingston said election year politics is what’s driving all the talk about food-safety legislation.
“Among other things, people vote for fear,” Kingston said. “Food safety sells.”




POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: