CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
Sept. 10, 2008 – 2:32 a.m.
Franken Primary Win One of Many Key Results From Tuesday’s Primaries
By Greg Giroux, CQ Staff
Entertainer-turned-candidate Al Franken easily won the nomination of Minnesota Democrats to challenge Republican Sen. Norm Coleman ; Delaware Democrats narrowly decided their primary for the state’s open governor’s seat in favor of state Treasurer Jack Markell, who will run on a party ticket topped by six-term Sen. Joseph R. Biden Jr. as he runs simultaneously for vice president and for Senate re-election; and voters in New York and New Hampshire decided the matchups for some of the year’s most competitive U.S. House races.
Those were among the highlights Tuesday as seven states — Delaware, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont and Wisconsin — held primary elections. It was the last big multi-state primary day, with just three states remaining to hold their nominating contests: Massachusetts on Sept. 16, Hawaii on Sept. 20 and Louisiana on Oct. 4 (delayed from Sept. 6 because of power failures and other disruptions caused by Hurricane Gustav).
The following is a summary of Tuesday’s results:
• Delaware. In a matchup of two statewide officeholders, Delaware’s Markell defeated Lt. Gov. John Carney by 51 percent to 49 percent, a difference of just less than 1,750 votes out of about 74,000 cast with all precincts reporting. The victory installs Markell as the front-runner over Republican primary winner Bill Lee for the general election contest in eight weeks to succeed two-term Democratic Gov. Ruth Ann Minner, who could not run for the office again under Delaware’ term-limit law.
Lee, a former judge, is a familiar figure, having run against Minner in 2004 and held her to an unexpectedly close 5 percentage-point margin. But while Lee easily won his primary Tuesday with 71 percent of the Republican primary vote, the contest drew just about 29,000 voters, much less than half the Democratic turnout. CQ rates the general election race as Democrat Favored.
Markell will be trying to extend the Democrats’ winning streak for governor to five elections, symbolic of the trend to that party in what once was a quintessential swing state. Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama now appears certain to carry a state in which he already was favored even before picking Biden as his running mate.
Biden is permitted under state law to seek re-election even as he campaigns for vice president. He was unopposed in the Senate primary, as was his Republican challenger, marketing and media consultant Christine O’Donnell. CQ rates the general election contest Safe Democratic. Should Biden win for vice president and for the Senate in November, he would resign the latter office, with the governor choosing an interim appointee to serve at least until a special election is held in November 2010.
Republican Rep. Michael N. Castle , a former governor and prominent GOP moderate who has represented Delaware’s lone House district since 1993, is heavily favored to win re-election against Democrat Karen Hartley-Nagle, the winner of a three-candidate primary. CQ rates the general election race as Safe Republican.
• Minnesota. Franken, an author and radio talk-show host perhaps best-known for his comedic tenure on “Saturday Night Live,” had no trouble winning a Senate primary that was his first contest for political office, shrugging off controversies that had popped up during the campaign concerning late tax payments and some of his racier satirical writings. In early returns, Franken led by 70 percent to 27 percent over Priscilla Lord Faris, a personal injury lawyer who is the daughter of a former state attorney general, with four other candidates taking minuscule vote shares.
Franken’s win pits him against first-term incumbent Coleman — who had 92 percent against a token Republican primary opponent — in a race that will definitely be one of the nation’s most expensive and almost certainly one of the year’s most combative. They will be joined on the ballot by Independence Party candidate Dean Barkley, who briefly served in the Senate as an interim appointee in late 2002 following Democratic Sen. Paul Wellstone’s death in a plane crash. CQ currently rates the general election contest as Leans Republican.
In the 1st Congressional District, which takes in Rochester and other southern Minnesota areas, oncologist Brian Davis led state Sen. Dick Day by 62 percent to 38 percent in the primary to decide the challenger to freshman Democratic Rep. Tim Walz , who scored an upset in 2006 over Republican Rep. Gil Gutknecht. Davis ran with the endorsement of the district’s Republican Party organization. CQ rates the general election race as Leans Democratic.
The most competitive general election House contest in the state may be the one to replace retiring nine-term moderate Republican Rep. Jim Ramstad in the 3rd District, which envelops suburbs north, west and south of the Twin Cities. Neither of the major-party nominees, Democratic lawyer and Iraq War veteran Ashwin Madia nor Republican state Rep. Erik Paulsen, drew primary opposition. CQ rates the general election race as No Clear Favorite.
Democrats also are targeting the 6th District — a socially conservative area that stretches from suburbs and exurbs north and east of the Twin Cities to St. Cloud in central Minnesota — where outspoken conservative freshman Republican Rep. Michele Bachmann will face El Tinklenberg, a former state transportation commissioner. Bachmann had 86 percent against one primary opponent, while Tinklenberg was unopposed. CQ rates the general election race as Republican Favored.
Franken Primary Win One of Many Key Results From Tuesday’s Primaries
• New Hampshire. This fall’s marquee Senate race in New Hampshire will feature a rematch of the close 2002 contest that Republican John E. Sununu , then the 1st District House member, won narrowly over Democrat Jeanne Shaheen, then the state’s governor. CQ Politics currently rates that highly competitive race as Leans Democratic. But with Sununu and Shaheen each breezing over one minor primary opponent, the most highly anticipated congressional result was in the 1st District House race — with the Republican primary setting up a rematch of the close 2006 race in which Democrat Carol Shea-Porter upset two-term Republican Rep. Jeb Bradley.
CQ Politics rates the 1st District general election as Leans Democratic.
With most precincts reporting, Bradley had 51 percent of the vote to best John Stephen, the former state health and human services commissioner, who had 47 percent. This, too, was a rematch of sorts, as Bradley had edged Stephen in a more crowded field for the 2002 Republican nomination in the then-open 1st District.
Shea-Porter was unopposed in the Democratic primary, as was her freshman Democratic colleague Paul W. Hodes , who in 2006 unseated six-term Republican Rep. Charles Bass in the 2nd, the more Democratic-leaning of New Hampshire’s two districts. Hodes’ general election opponent is Republican Jennifer Horn, a conservative talk-show host who won a five-candidate Republican primary with 40 percent of the vote. State Sen. Bob Clegg ran second with 34 percent. CQ Politics rates this general election as Democrat Favored.
The popularity of Democratic Gov. John Lynch makes him a heavy favorite to win a third two-year term over the Republican nominee, state Sen. Joseph Kenney. This race is rated as Safe Democratic.
CQ Politics has published a more detailed analysis of the New Hampshire primary returns.
• New York. With more U.S. House districts than the combined total of the other six states voting Tuesday, New York had the busiest primary day.
The favored candidate won the Democratic nomination for what appears to be the party’s clearest shot to pick up a Republican-held House seat, with New York City Councilman Michael McMahon easily winning his primary for the seat in the 13th District. That is the district, made up of Staten Island and a small piece of Brooklyn, that unexpectedly was left open after Republican incumbent Vito J. Fossella admitted to having a child from an extramarital affair and decided to retire. Although Republicans long dominated this district, they floundered at recruiting after Fossella’s stunning downfall while the Democratic establishment rallied around the politically experienced McMahon.
That core party support helped boost McMahon to a 75 percent to 25 percent primary win over 2006 nominee Stephen A. Harrison, who contended he deserved another chance after he held Fossella to 57 percent last time despite getting greatly outspent. That sent McMahon on to a general election matchup with Republican former state Rep. Robert Straniere, who gained the Staten Island Republican Party’s endorsement after several top Republican officials declined to run and after the first candidate tapped to replace Fossella, retired Wall Street executive Frank Powers, died of a heart attack.
Straniere won his primary with 59 percent over a little-known Republican opponent. But the tough odds he faces for the general election were underscored by this statistic: He received fewer votes winning the Republican primary than Harrison received while badly losing the Democratic contest. CQ rates the general election race as Democrat Favored.
By contrast, the primary to nominate the Democratic contender for another top takeover bid, this one in the 26th District at the other end of the state, resulted in at least a mild upset. Alice Kryzan, a lawyer from Buffalo running to succeed retiring five-term Republican Rep. Thomas M. Reynolds , did not receive as much of the spotlight during the primary campaign as did opponents Jon Powers, an Iraq War veteran-turned-critic, and businessman Jack Davis, seeking his third consecutive nomination after holding Reynolds to a 4-point win in 2006. But she also steered clear of the vitriol that infused campaign exchanges between those two, which helped her claim victory with 42 percent of the vote to 36 percent for Powers and 23 percent for Davis.
Kryzan now faces Republican businessman Christopher Lee, a businessman who was unopposed in the GOP primary, in a general election race CQ Politics rates as Leans Republican.
The other unexpected results took place in the Albany-region 21st District, where former state Rep. Paul Tonko won a five-way Democratic primary with 39 percent of the vote — a victory that makes him the strong favorite to succeed retiring 10-term Rep. Michael R. McNulty in the strongly Democratic district. Regarded as an underdog, in part because he lagged a bit at fundraising, Tonko nonetheless outran Tracey Brooks, a former aide to New York Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton , who had 30 percent and Albany County Legislator Phil Steck, who took 19 percent. Republican James Buhrmaster, a Schenectady County legislator, won the much lower turnout GOP primary.
Franken Primary Win One of Many Key Results From Tuesday’s Primaries
Other key fall matchups were decided without primary competition. Democrat Dan Maffei, a former congressional aide who came within 2 points of unseating long-time Republican Rep. James T. Walsh in the 25th District in 2006, will face Republican Dale Sweetland, a former chairman of the Onondaga County legislature, for the seat Walsh left open to retire, with CQ Politics rating the race as Leans Democratic. Republican Rep. John R. “Randy” Kuhl Jr. of the 29th District faces a rematch of the 2006 race in which he defeated Democrat Eric Massa, a Navy veteran, by just 3 points: CQ Politics’ rating is Leans Republican. And in the Republicans’ most vigorous effort to take back a New York seat that they lost in 2006, Democratic freshman Rep. Kirsten Gillibrand of the 20th District faces a challenge by Sandy Treadwell, a former state Republican Party chairman, in a race CQ Politics rates as Leans Democratic.
The only New York incumbent who faced serious primary opposition was 10th District Democrat Edolphus Towns , who won by 67 percent to 33 percent over Kevin Powell, a political activist who was an inaugural cast member on the MTV program “The Real World.” Towns, who also faced serious primary opposition in 2000 and 2006, is a shoo-in to win a new term in a heavily black and Democratic area of Brooklyn that includes Bedford-Stuyvesant and Canarsie.
CQ Politics published a detailed treatment of the New York primary results.
• Rhode Island. Democrat Jack Reed , an overwhelming favorite to win a third Senate term, found no obstacle in breezing past primary opponent Christopher Young with 87 percent of the primary vote. His general election opponent, Republican Bob Tingle, also challenged Reed in 2002 and drew just 22 percent of the vote. The state’s two House members, Democrats Patrick J. Kennedy and Jim Langevin , were unopposed in the primary and also should be easily re-elected in a state that is one of the nation’s leading Democratic Party strongholds. CQ Politics rates the Senate race and the House races as Safe Democratic.
• Vermont. Tuesday’s primary confirmed a general election matchup between Republican Gov. Jim Douglas, who has won three two-year terms, and Democrat Gaye Symington, the state House Speaker. Though Vermont is one of the nation’s most Democratic-leaning states in presidential contests and at most other levels, its “Yankee Republican” heritage occasionally shows through for candidates, such as Douglas, who state voters deem moderate enough. Some Democratic strategists nonetheless are touting Symington, who entered the race on the late side, as a sleeper candidate for a November upset. CQ Politics currently rates the race as Safe Republican, though that rating is subject to re-evaluation.
Democratic Rep. Peter Welch , who was first elected in 2006 to the seat liberal independent Rep. Bernard Sanders left open for a successful Senate bid, easily beat one primary challenger for the state’s at-large House district — and doesn’t face Republican opposition in November. CQ Politics rates the House race as Safe Democratic.
• Wisconsin. Democratic freshman Rep. Steve Kagen and Republican John Gard, a former state Assembly Speaker, were unopposed in their primaries in the northeastern 8th District. They have thus been going head-to-head for months in a rematch of the 2006 open-seat election that Kagen, an allergist then making his first bid for public office, won by 2 percentage points — a rare Democratic victory in a conservative-leaning, Green Bay-centered district. CQ Politics rates the race as Leans Democratic
Among Wisconsin’s eight U.S. House incumbents, the only one who faced primary opposition on Tuesday was 15-term Republican Rep. F. James Sensenbrenner Jr. , who took 78 percent of the primary vote in the strongly Republican 5th District in suburban Milwaukee. Sensenbrenner is heavily favored to win another term in November.




POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: