CQ TODAY ONLINE NEWS
June 12, 2009 – 10:14 p.m.
Compromises Threaten Energy Bill’s Chances on Senate Floor
By Coral Davenport, CQ Staff
After more than two months of horse-trading and compromises, a Senate commmittee is on the brink of approving energy legislation with something for just about everybody to hate.
Jeff Bingaman , D-N.M., chairman of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, hoped to complete work on the draft bill by now but postponed a vote until next week because of scheduling conflicts.
The bill, intended to be the main Senate vehicle for President Obama’s energy agenda, would boost the amount of electricity generated from renewable sources, expand offshore drilling in the Gulf of Mexico and streamline siting of long-distance power lines.
But many of the compromises struck to advance the bill in committee threaten to blow up when the measure reaches the Senate floor.
Language that would allow offshore drilling in a vast tract of the eastern Gulf of Mexico was designed to curry support from pro-drilling Republicans, but it has alienated Bill Nelson of Florida and other conservation-minded Democrats.
And without a provision — rejected in committee — allowing coastal states to share in the royalties paid for drilling in federal waters, the expanded drilling may not be enough to bring the Republicans along.
Meanwhile, no one seems satisfied by the renewable-electricity mandate, the centerpiece of the bill. The legislation would require utilities to produce 15 percent of the nation’s power from renewable sources, such as wind and solar, by 2021, of which 4 percent could be met by increasing energy efficiency.
To gain the support of Democrats from states with few wind or solar resources, Bingaman agreed to water down the mandate from the 25 percent standard sought by President Obama and the 20 percent by 2020 standard in climate change legislation (
Despite the concession, most Republicans remain staunchly opposed to the mandate. But the renewable-energy industry, along with Democrats tied to the environmental movement, say it is now too weak to create real incentives for an expansion of renewable-energy production.
Revenue Sharing
Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, the Energy panel’s ranking Republican, has expressed reservations about the renewable electricity standard but has said she could reluctantly support it if the broader bill includes strong language to expand domestic oil and gas production.
She and other Republicans say language allowing coastal states to share offshore-drilling revenue is critical to expanding offshore production because it would provide an incentive for states to support drilling off their coastlines. A 2006 energy law (PL 109-432) that expanded drilling in the Gulf allows four coastal states to share some of the revenue.
But Bingaman adamantly opposes expanding revenue sharing, arguing that offshore resources belong to the entire country and that any revenue should be dedicated to reducing the deficit.
The 2006 legislation was enacted after senators agreed to ban drilling too close to Florida’s shorelines. Nelson said he voted for it after brokering a deal with then-Minority Leader Harry Reid , D-Nev., to carve a buffer zone off of Florida.
Nelson said the language in the new energy bill would break that agreement, and he has threatened a filibuster to block it. Nelson took to the Senate floor Thursday to condemn the legislation, complete with maps and photographs designed to illustrate what he described as a threat to Florida’s tourist industry and interference with offshore military training areas.
“We will kill this because there are too many of us who are concerned about this,” Nelson said.
The provision’s sponsor, North Dakota Democrat Byron L. Dorgan , said he was not concerned about the filibuster threat.
“There will be a lot of controversial pieces in the bill, but we’ll have enough votes to pass it,” he said.
However, Reid — now the majority leader — acknowledged through a spokesman that he had not forgotten the 2006 deal with Nelson.
“There is a long road between the committee’s action and the full Senate consideration, and Sen. Nelson’s concerns will have to be factored into how the Senate proceeds,” said Jim Manley, Reid’s communications director.
New Jersey Democrat Robert Menendez said the compromises that watered down the renewable-electricity mandate while promoting new drilling in the Gulf made it increasingly less likely that he would support the bill in its current form. He added that he would consider joining Nelson’s filibuster.
“I haven’t decided yet, but I’m inclined to be supportive,” he said.
When asked about the slings coming at his bill from all directions, Bingaman was typically low-key.
“There are so many views, so many lines in the sand,” he said. “We’ll have to see what can be worked out.”




Comments
Three years ago when reid, peloski, clinton and obama and the DEMOCRATS passed the energy bill that drove gasoline prices up to almost $5 a gallon they darn near gutted the hard working middle class taxpayers. Then obama-ACORN-housing scandal with dodd, frank, reid and peloski kicked in and destroyed the housing industry. Then Schummmmmmmer-dodd banking scandal piled on. Then we get obama in and obama and his Auto CZARS kill Chrysler and GM. It time to develop a realistic energy policy of using oil we have under our borders of the United States and on PUBLIC OWNED PROPERTY. It time to build 100 Nuclear Plants for electricity. Anybody that has had to depend on wind(windmills to water their livestock or humans know it is not dependable and over priced). Solar power has limited capabilities but the Federal and State governments should not be subsidizing it. The Musem in Denver where obama had to sign his ARRA(America Rape and Reaping ACT) that has raped the taxpayers again has a 107 year payback for its solar system and thats does include replacing any solar panels during that 107 years yes that is one hundred and seven years. Now obama don't tell me you got any common sense that going to save the federal government trillions to pay for your foney fraudulent National Heathcare. obama we taxpayers are sick of the rape of the taxpayers and in 2010 we will throw your thugs out and in 2012 you the head thug if you haven't been impeached.
POST A COMMENT
Oops! The following errors must be addressed: